What are the key considerations when negotiating territorial rights in a franchise contract?

1 The purpose of territorial rights

Territorial rights are clauses in a franchise contract that specify the geographic area and the level of protection that the franchisee has to operate the franchised business. The purpose of territorial rights is to avoid or reduce the competition and conflict between the franchisor and the franchisee, or among different franchisees, within the same market. Territorial rights can also help the franchisor to control the quality and consistency of the brand, and the franchisee to secure a reasonable return on investment.

2 The types of territorial rights

When granting a franchisee territorial rights, there are several options depending on the level of exclusivity and enforceability. The most common types are exclusive territory, in which the franchisee has sole right to operate in the area and the franchisor cannot sell or grant any other franchises or operate any other outlets; protected territory, where the franchisee has right to operate but the franchisor cannot sell or grant any other franchises; non-exclusive territory, where the franchisee has right to operate but the franchisor can sell or grant other franchises with some limitations or conditions; and no territory, where the franchisee has no specific right to operate and the franchisor can sell or grant any number of franchises or operate any number of outlets in any area.

3 The factors affecting territorial rights

The size, shape, and location of the territorial rights can vary depending on a variety of factors, such as the nature and characteristics of the franchised business, the goals and objectives of the franchisor and franchisee, and the legal and regulatory environment. This includes elements such as the product or service offered, the target market, the customer base, the distribution channels, the marketing strategies, the competitive environment, the expansion plans, the growth potential, the profitability, the risk tolerance, the relationship quality, franchise laws, antitrust laws, consumer protection laws, and contractual terms and conditions.

4 The benefits and drawbacks of territorial rights

Territorial rights can have both benefits and drawbacks for the franchisor and the franchisee, depending on the type and extent of the rights granted. The benefits of territorial rights can include a competitive advantage, a loyal customer base, a higher market share, a lower marketing cost, and a higher profitability for the franchisee, as well as a motivated and committed franchisee, a faster and easier market penetration, a lower operational cost, and a higher brand recognition for the franchisor. However, territorial rights can also limit the franchisee's flexibility, innovation, and diversification, and expose them to the risk of market saturation, obsolescence, or decline. Similarly, these rights can limit the franchisor's control, oversight, and standardization while exposing them to the risk of underperformance, litigation, or reputation damage.

5 The best practices for negotiating territorial rights

Negotiating territorial rights can be a complex and delicate process, as it involves finding a balance between the interests and expectations of both parties, as well as taking into account the market and legal realities. To ensure a successful negotiation, it is best to conduct a thorough market research and analysis, define clear and realistic goals and objectives, communicate openly and honestly, and seek professional advice and assistance. Doing so will help you understand the demand and supply of the franchised business, the competitive landscape, the growth opportunities in the relevant area, determine suitable and feasible territorial rights for the franchised business, communicate concerns and issues effectively, resolve disputes and conflicts, ensure compliance with applicable laws and regulations, draft and review contractual terms and conditions, and protect the rights of both parties.

6 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?