登录查看更多内容

Last updated on 2024年5月16日

How can economics help design optimal defense budgets?

由人工智能和领英社区提供技术支持

National defense is a vital public good that protects the security and sovereignty of a nation. However, it also involves significant trade-offs and opportunity costs, as defense spending competes with other public and private needs. How can economics help design optimal defense budgets that balance efficiency, effectiveness, and equity? In this article, we will explore some of the key concepts and tools that economists use to analyze and advise on defense policy.

此文章中的业界达人

由社区从 10 条内容中精选。了解更多

John Siraut

Senior Director, Economics at Jacobs
Ng Zi Yang (AFP?)

6-Figure Advisor | Wealth Management | Investment Management | Trusted Advisor for Educators & Professionals | Bespoke…
Rafael Vargas

Director Comercial especializado en ayudar a empresas en el área fiscal, jurídica y contable con estrategias…

1 Public goods and externalities

One of the main reasons why national defense is a public good is that it is non-rival and non-excludable. This means that one person's consumption of defense does not reduce the amount available for others, and that no one can be prevented from enjoying the benefits of defense. However, this also creates a problem of free-riding, where some people may underpay or avoid paying for defense, while still benefiting from it. Moreover, defense spending may generate positive or negative externalities, which are effects on third parties that are not reflected in the market price. For example, a strong defense may deter aggression and promote regional stability, which are positive externalities. On the other hand, a high defense budget may crowd out other public spending or increase the risk of conflict, which are negative externalities.

添加您的观点

Ng Zi Yang (AFP?)

6-Figure Advisor | Wealth Management | Investment Management | Trusted Advisor for Educators & Professionals | Bespoke & Holistic Retirement Planning
举报内容
Economics plays a crucial role in designing optimal defense budgets by providing tools and frameworks for making informed decisions about resource allocation. Here's how: Cost-Benefit Analysis: Economics emphasizes weighing costs and benefits. In defense spending, this translates to analyzing the potential threats, the effectiveness of different defense strategies (military hardware, training, cyber defense etc.), and the associated costs for each. The goal is to find the most cost-effective strategy that provides adequate security.

已翻译

赞
Rafael Vargas

Director Comercial especializado en ayudar a empresas en el área fiscal, jurídica y contable con estrategias personalizadas para cada caso | Linkedin Top Voice en Economía
举报内容
La economía desempe?a un papel fundamental en el dise?o de presupuestos de defensa óptimos al proporcionar un marco analítico sólido para evaluar las necesidades de seguridad nacional en relación con los recursos disponibles. Al considerar factores como el costo de oportunidad, la eficiencia en el gasto y el impacto económico a largo plazo, los responsables de la formulación de políticas pueden tomar decisiones informadas para asignar fondos de manera estratégica. Además, la economía puede ayudar a identificar áreas de inversión prioritarias, optimizando la capacidad de defensa y garantizando la protección nacional de manera eficaz y eficiente.

已翻译

赞
SURESH BABU

Founder | Mentor | CEO - Einsatz Tech. LLP | CFO-The One Accountant, Dubai | IIM Indore, Certified PG in Emerging CFO | Harvard Business School Boston, USA-Certfn: in Finance | Finance Specialist with AI&ML Automation|
举报内容
Use technology for budgeting & forecasting collaboration Cloud-Based Planning Tools (?? + ): ● Ditch the spreadsheets! ♀? These tools allow real-time access and updates for everyone on the team, keeping everyone on the same page. Collaborative Forecasting Platforms ( +): ● Work together to build and refine forecasts based on shared data and insights. This fosters a sense of ownership and accountability. Automated Data Collection ( + ): ● Reduce manual work and errors by automating data collection from different financial systems. Less time crunching numbers, more time for analysis! ???? Communication & Feedback Tools ( + ): ● Use built-in chat features Mobile Accessibility ( + $):

已翻译

赞
José Luiz da Rocha Mendes

Diretor de Finan?as, Estratégia & M&A
举报内容
Economics, especially microeconomics, is key in designing optimal defense budgets by ensuring efficient resource allocation. Here are the main points: - Marginal Cost-Benefit Analysis: Evaluate if the benefits of increased defense spending outweigh the costs. - Opportunity Cost: Consider what is foregone, such as investments in education or health, when funds are allocated to defense. - Budget Constraints: Apply constrained optimization to maximize defense outputs within budget limits. - Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: Compare costs and effectiveness of different defense strategies to prioritize spending. -These principles help in crafting a defense budget that is both effective in meeting security needs and economically prudent.

已翻译

赞
José Luiz da Rocha Mendes

Diretor de Finan?as, Estratégia & M&A
举报内容
Economics can help design optimal defense budgets through scenario analysis and positive asymmetries: - Scenario Analysis: Economists project different future states to evaluate potential threats and resource needs. This informs decision-making and efficient resource allocation to areas with the highest impact. - Positive Asymmetries: Identifying areas where small investments yield large benefits ensures defense budgets maximize returns. This includes investing in advanced technologies or strategic alliances that enhance capabilities without substantial spending. These approaches create balanced, effective defense budgets that meet security needs while optimizing resources.

已翻译

赞

加载更多内容

2 Cost-benefit analysis and budget constraints

To design optimal defense budgets, economists use cost-benefit analysis (CBA) to compare the marginal benefits and marginal costs of different levels and types of defense spending. The marginal benefit of defense is the additional value or utility that a unit of defense spending provides to society, while the marginal cost is the additional sacrifice or opportunity cost that a unit of defense spending imposes on society. The optimal level of defense spending is where the marginal benefit equals the marginal cost, which maximizes social welfare. However, CBA is not always easy or straightforward, as it involves measuring and valuing intangible and uncertain outcomes, such as security, peace, and deterrence. Moreover, CBA is subject to budget constraints, which limit the amount of resources available for defense spending. Budget constraints may be determined by factors such as fiscal policy, tax revenue, borrowing capacity, and macroeconomic conditions.

添加您的观点

3 Allocation and efficiency

Another aspect of optimal defense budgeting is how to allocate the available resources among different defense programs and activities. Economists use the concept of allocative efficiency to evaluate how well the defense budget reflects the preferences and priorities of society. Allocative efficiency occurs when the defense budget is distributed in such a way that no one can be made better off without making someone else worse off. This implies that the defense budget should reflect the marginal rate of substitution (MRS) between different defense goods and services, which is the rate at which society is willing to trade off one defense good or service for another. For example, if society values air force more than navy, then the MRS between air force and navy is high, and the defense budget should allocate more resources to air force than navy.

添加您的观点

Paula Costa

Especialista em Finan?as Pessoais | Personal Finance Expert (Investidora e reformada aos 48 anos)
举报内容
This is not my area of expertise. However, as a manager and financial professional, I think the best way to estimate the marginal rate of substitution (MRS) is to conduct a thorough research and analysis on the preferences and priorities of society in terms of defense spending. This could involve surveys, focus groups, and other methods to gather information on how individuals value different defense goods and services and are willing to trade off one for another. Such information should then be used to inform the decision-making process. Transparency and accountability are essential to the process. Regular evaluation and review of the defense budget can also help to ensure that it is reflecting the preferences and trade-offs of society.

已翻译

赞

4 Equity and distribution

A final consideration for optimal defense budgeting is how to ensure that the defense budget is fair and equitable for different groups and individuals in society. Economists use the concept of distributive equity to assess how the defense budget affects the distribution of income, wealth, and welfare among different segments of society. Distributive equity may be based on different criteria, such as need, merit, contribution, or entitlement. For example, some may argue that the defense budget should be progressive, meaning that those who have more ability or willingness to pay should pay more for defense, while those who have less should pay less or receive subsidies. Others may argue that the defense budget should be proportional, meaning that everyone should pay the same proportion of their income or wealth for defense. Distributive equity may also involve compensating or rewarding those who bear more costs or risks for defense, such as military personnel, veterans, or allies.

添加您的观点

John Siraut

Senior Director, Economics at Jacobs
举报内容
Like many AI generated articles this is very simplistic, provides no great insights and bears little reality to how economics is used in relation to defense spending.

已翻译

赞

Economics

+ 关注

给文章评分

我们借助人工智能创建了此文章。您认为这篇文章怎么样？

很棒不太好

举报此文章

查看全部

How can economics help design optimal defense budgets?

1

2

3

4

1 Public goods and externalities

2 Cost-benefit analysis and budget constraints

3 Allocation and efficiency

4 Equity and distribution

Economics

给文章评分

感谢您的反馈

更多Economics相关文章

更多相关阅读内容

How can economics help design optimal defense budgets?

1

2

3

4

1 Public goods and externalities

2 Cost-benefit analysis and budget constraints

3 Allocation and efficiency

4 Equity and distribution

Economics

给文章评分

感谢您的反馈

查看其他技能