登录查看更多内容

An employee disputes their performance review. How will you navigate this challenging situation?

由人工智能和领英社区提供技术支持

Performance reviews are a critical aspect of employee development and organizational growth. They provide a structured way to assess an individual's contributions and identify areas for improvement. However, when an employee disputes their performance review, it can be a challenging situation to navigate. As a manager or human resources professional, your approach to this delicate issue must be tactful, fair, and constructive to maintain a positive work environment and ensure the employee feels heard and valued.

此文章中的业界达人

由社区从 6 条内容中精选。了解更多

Rodrigo Watanabe

Gerente de Planejamento Comercial e Compras | OTB | Gest?o de Estoques | S&OP | Forecast | Estratégia de Sortimento
Dharvi Patil

Human Resources Manager at R. R. Infraprojects Pvt. Ltd,

1 Listen Actively

When faced with a disputed performance review, the first step is to listen actively to the employee's concerns. This means giving them your full attention, acknowledging their feelings without judgment, and seeking to understand their perspective. By doing so, you demonstrate respect and open the lines of communication. It's important to let the employee express themselves fully before responding, as this can often help to de-escalate the situation and lay the groundwork for a productive dialogue.

添加您的观点

Dharvi Patil

Human Resources Manager at R. R. Infraprojects Pvt. Ltd,
举报内容
Navigating a disputed performance review requires a balanced approach. Begin by actively listening to the employee’s concerns and validating their perspective. Review the feedback together, providing specific examples to clarify the ratings. Remain open to adjustments if the employee presents compelling evidence. Encourage a constructive dialogue focused on growth and improvement. Document the discussion and any agreed-upon changes, ensuring both parties are aligned on expectations moving forward.

已翻译

赞
Rodrigo Watanabe

Gerente de Planejamento Comercial e Compras | OTB | Gest?o de Estoques | S&OP | Forecast | Estratégia de Sortimento
举报内容
Em uma situa??o de contesta??o de avalia??o de desempenho, é importante entender o que motivou essa contesta??o. Saber ouvir é essencial para compreender o ponto de vista do funcionário e, ao mesmo tempo, estabelecer um canal de comunica??o eficaz. Mostre respeito e esteja aberto a entender a perspectiva dele; isso ajuda a acalmar a situa??o e facilita a busca por uma solu??o. Se surgirem novas informa??es, esteja disposto a revisar a avalia??o e explique claramente os critérios utilizados, para chegar a um entendimento melhor.

已翻译

赞

2 Review Objectively

After listening to the employee, review the performance evaluation objectively. Look at the metrics, goals, and feedback provided to ensure they were clear, measurable, and aligned with the employee's role. It's crucial to have a solid foundation for the review so that you can discuss specific points rather than general dissatisfaction. If any part of the review process was flawed or if new information comes to light, be prepared to reassess and adjust the evaluation as necessary.

添加您的观点

Rodrigo Watanabe

Gerente de Planejamento Comercial e Compras | OTB | Gest?o de Estoques | S&OP | Forecast | Estratégia de Sortimento
举报内容
Ao revisar a avalia??o após conversar com o funcionário, fa?a isso com calma e objetividade. Verifique os números, metas e feedback para garantir que tudo está alinhado com o desempenho real do funcionário. Evite o "achismo" e baseie a discuss?o em dados concretos. Consulte também a equipe e outros gestores para ter uma vis?o mais completa. Se descobrir erros ou novas informa??es relevantes, ajuste a avalia??o conforme necessário. Registre todas as mudan?as e explique-as claramente para o funcionário, garantindo transparência para evitar mal-entendidos.

已翻译

赞

3 Provide Evidence

In discussing the review with the employee, provide evidence to support the evaluation. This could include examples of work, records of accomplishments or incidents, and feedback from peers or clients. Clear evidence can help clarify why certain assessments were made and guide the conversation towards constructive feedback rather than personal opinions. Remember, the goal is to help the employee understand the evaluation and how they can improve, not to defend the review at all costs.

添加您的观点

4 Encourage Dialogue

Encourage a two-way dialogue where both you and the employee can share viewpoints and work towards mutual understanding. This is not about winning an argument but about finding common ground and setting actionable goals for the future. Ask open-ended questions to encourage the employee to reflect on their performance and consider their own areas for growth. This can also help them feel more involved in the process and less like they are being judged unilaterally.

添加您的观点

Mohamed Saber

Human Resources Coordinator | Talent Acquisition, Data Analysis, Data Visualization
举报内容
Open Dialogue: Ask questions: Encourage open communication by asking clarifying questions. Address concerns: Directly address the employee's specific points of disagreement. Provide evidence: If necessary, use specific examples or data to support your assessment.

已翻译

赞

5 Plan Development

Based on the discussion, work together to plan a development strategy that addresses any performance gaps and leverages the employee’s strengths. This plan should include specific, achievable goals and may involve additional training, mentoring, or changes in responsibilities. It's important that the employee feels supported in their professional growth and that there is a clear path forward that both parties have agreed upon.

添加您的观点

Rodrigo Watanabe

Gerente de Planejamento Comercial e Compras | OTB | Gest?o de Estoques | S&OP | Forecast | Estratégia de Sortimento
举报内容
Ao criar um plano de desenvolvimento para um funcionário, foque em corrigir lacunas de desempenho e aproveitar seus pontos fortes. Use a metodologia SMART para definir metas claras e realistas, e inclua treinamentos, orienta??o e novos desafios. Garanta que o plano tenha etapas práticas e acordadas por ambos, com marcos para acompanhar o progresso. Mantenha uma comunica??o aberta para entender as necessidades do funcionário e documente tudo para assegurar que todos estejam alinhados. O objetivo é melhorar o desempenho e engajar o funcionário, mostrando compromisso com seu crescimento e bem-estar.

已翻译

赞
Mohamed Saber

Human Resources Coordinator | Talent Acquisition, Data Analysis, Data Visualization
举报内容
Offer Ongoing Support: Check-in regularly: Monitor the employee's progress and provide guidance as needed. Maintain open communication: Encourage ongoing dialogue to prevent future misunderstandings.

已翻译

赞

6 Follow Up

Finally, establish a follow-up plan to monitor progress and continue the conversation. This could involve scheduled check-ins, revised objectives, or new projects that allow the employee to demonstrate improvement. Regular follow-up ensures that the performance management process is ongoing and adaptive, rather than a once-a-year event. It also shows the employee that you are invested in their success and willing to support them through their development journey.

添加您的观点

Performance Management

+ 关注

给文章评分

我们借助人工智能创建了此文章。您认为这篇文章怎么样？

很棒不太好

举报此文章

查看全部

An employee disputes their performance review. How will you navigate this challenging situation?

1

2

3

4

5

6

1 Listen Actively

2 Review Objectively

3 Provide Evidence

4 Encourage Dialogue

5 Plan Development

6 Follow Up

Performance Management

给文章评分

感谢您的反馈

更多Performance Management相关文章

更多相关阅读内容

An employee disputes their performance review. How will you navigate this challenging situation?

1

2

3

4

5

6

1 Listen Actively

2 Review Objectively

3 Provide Evidence

4 Encourage Dialogue

5 Plan Development

6 Follow Up

Performance Management

给文章评分

感谢您的反馈

查看其他技能