登录查看更多内容

What are the most effective ways to measure macroeconomic policy success?

由人工智能和领英社区提供技术支持

Macroeconomic policy refers to the actions taken by governments and central banks to influence the aggregate level of economic activity, such as output, employment, inflation, and trade. Macroeconomic policy can have significant effects on the welfare of millions of people, as well as the performance of various sectors and industries. Therefore, it is important to evaluate how successful macroeconomic policy is in achieving its objectives and improving the quality of life for the population. But how can we measure macroeconomic policy success? What indicators and criteria should we use to assess the outcomes and impacts of macroeconomic policy? In this article, we will explore some of the most effective ways to measure macroeconomic policy success, and discuss some of the challenges and limitations of these methods.

此文章中的业界达人

由社区从 7 条内容中精选。了解更多

Pavan Kumar Thimmavajjala

Economist, Quantitative Researcher, Transport & Urban Economics and Planning - UGC-NET Certification (2021)
Miguel Cueva, MBA

Tesorería | Finanzas | Docente Universitario | Contabilidad Gerencial | Control de gestión | Mentor en Innovación…
Thiago Souza, MBA, AAI

Educador Financeiro | Palestrante | Assessor de investimentos | Perspective Investimentos | BTG Pactual

1 Growth and stability

One of the most common and intuitive ways to measure macroeconomic policy success is to look at the growth and stability of key macroeconomic variables, such as gross domestic product (GDP), unemployment, inflation, and the balance of payments. These variables reflect the level and variation of economic activity, and are often used as indicators of the overall health and performance of an economy. Macroeconomic policy can be considered successful if it promotes sustained and balanced growth, low and stable unemployment, moderate and predictable inflation, and a manageable external position. However, these variables are not always reliable or comparable across countries and time periods, and may not capture the distributional and environmental aspects of economic well-being.

添加您的观点

Pavan Kumar Thimmavajjala

Economist, Quantitative Researcher, Transport & Urban Economics and Planning - UGC-NET Certification (2021)
举报内容
Macroeconomic policy and its success, firstly is for a long run. So assessing the hits or misses for a short period (a year or less) is impractical. We have to look at what a macro policy targets and trace its multiplier effects. For instance, take the monetary and fiscal policy. The Fed Res attempts to improve liquidity by reducing the Fed Funds rate. This is traced to increased credit, more investments in certain sectors & more incomes. On the fiscal front, if the yearly rollout of funds for urban bodies goes up, the macro effect can be assessed in terms of more public transit facilities etc. So you've got to assess it based on the objectives, the priorities, strategies adopted and how resources are pooled for the same. Time too!

已翻译

赞
Miguel Cueva, MBA

Tesorería | Finanzas | Docente Universitario | Contabilidad Gerencial | Control de gestión | Mentor en Innovación Financiera
举报内容
Según mi experiencia, la política macroeconómica adoptada por el Banco Central, busca el crecimiento sostenible de la economía, indicadores como crecimiento objetivo del PIB, inflación controlada dentro del rango meta y un tipo de cambio estable (sin variaciones bruscas) dan credibilidad a un país y generan escenarios de confianza para que se ejecuten mayores inversiones, lo cual se refleja en mayores puestos de trabajo. Por ejemplo: Una economía en constante crecimiento (no en piloto automático) brinda las garantías necesarias para que inviertan en un país y bien sabemos que sin inversión, no hay crecimiento.

已翻译

赞
Thiago Souza, MBA, AAI

Educador Financeiro | Palestrante | Assessor de investimentos | Perspective Investimentos | BTG Pactual
举报内容
O crescimento do Produto Interno Bruto (PIB) é um indicador-chave do desempenho econ?mico de um país. O sucesso da política macroecon?mica geralmente é refletido em taxas saudáveis de crescimento do PIB ao longo do tempo. Um PIB crescente indica aumento na produ??o de bens e servi?os e, portanto, melhoria no padr?o de vida.

已翻译

赞

2 Happiness and well-being

Another way to measure macroeconomic policy success is to look at the happiness and well-being of the people affected by the policy. Happiness and well-being are subjective measures of how people feel about their lives, and can reflect their satisfaction with various aspects of their economic, social, and personal situations. Macroeconomic policy can be considered successful if it enhances the happiness and well-being of the majority of the population, and reduces the gaps and inequalities among different groups. However, happiness and well-being are difficult to define and measure, and may not be directly influenced by macroeconomic policy, but rather by other factors, such as culture, values, and preferences.

添加您的观点

3 Efficiency and productivity

A third way to measure macroeconomic policy success is to look at the efficiency and productivity of the economy. Efficiency and productivity are measures of how well an economy uses its available resources, such as labor, capital, technology, and natural resources, to produce goods and services. Macroeconomic policy can be considered successful if it improves the efficiency and productivity of the economy, and fosters innovation and competitiveness. However, efficiency and productivity are not always easy to calculate or compare, and may not reflect the quality or sustainability of the production process or the output.

添加您的观点

Thiago Souza, MBA, AAI

Educador Financeiro | Palestrante | Assessor de investimentos | Perspective Investimentos | BTG Pactual
举报内容
eficiência e produtividade s?o indicadores-chave do desempenho econ?mico e s?o essenciais para a análise e aprimoramento de processos produtivos em empresas e economias. Empresas e governos frequentemente buscam aumentar a eficiência e a produtividade como meio de impulsionar o crescimento econ?mico e melhorar o padr?o de vida.

已翻译

赞
Nicole A. Lindsay

Quantitative Analyst at the Richmond Fed, Applied Economics MA
举报内容
Although efficiency and productivity are difficult to measure, the Cobb-Douglas production function provides a good starting point. Assuming Y = AK^(a)L^(1-a) (generally a = 1/3), one could find variables pertinent to the policy to represent output (Y), labor (L), and capital input (K) to isolate and reasonably estimate total factor productivity (A). Though the resulting value of A may not be in any intuitive metric, it can certainly be used to compare changes in productivity over time. Using a difference-in-differences model would be one way to use this A to calculate the impact of a policy on a treated group's productivity.

已翻译

赞

4 Institutions and governance

A fourth way to measure macroeconomic policy success is to look at the institutions and governance of the economy. Institutions and governance are the formal and informal rules and norms that shape the behavior and interactions of economic agents, such as governments, firms, households, and markets. Macroeconomic policy can be considered successful if it strengthens the institutions and governance of the economy, and enhances transparency, accountability, participation, and coordination. However, institutions and governance are not always observable or measurable, and may not be directly affected by macroeconomic policy, but rather by historical, political, and social factors.

添加您的观点

Miguel Cueva, MBA

Tesorería | Finanzas | Docente Universitario | Contabilidad Gerencial | Control de gestión | Mentor en Innovación Financiera
举报内容
La política macroeconómica (dependiendo de la ejecución del modelo) es la base para el desarrollo de un país, pero hay que tener en cuenta que es el punto de inicio. Las instituciones de un país son aquellos pilares que te dan el marcador del desarrollo a través de la percepción de los habitantes de un país. Poniendo un caso extremo, de nada sirve crecer el PIB de forma constante a dígitos atractivos si la delincuencia, un servicio de salud precario y la corrupción son el pan de cada día de los noticieros. Dicho de otro modo: Creces en números abstractos, pero tu calidad de vida no guarda relación con dicho crecimiento macroeconómico. Es ahí donde los Gobiernos debe articular esfuerzos para que el desarrollo llegue a todos.

已翻译

赞

5 Trade-offs and challenges

As we have seen, there are different ways to measure macroeconomic policy success, and each of them has its own advantages and disadvantages. Moreover, there are trade-offs and challenges involved in designing and implementing macroeconomic policy, and in evaluating its effects. For example, macroeconomic policy may have to balance the short-term and long-term goals, the domestic and external objectives, and the aggregate and distributional impacts. Macroeconomic policy may also face uncertainty and complexity, as well as political and institutional constraints. Therefore, measuring macroeconomic policy success is not a simple or straightforward task, but rather a complex and multidimensional one.

添加您的观点

6 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

添加您的观点

Miguel Cueva, MBA

Tesorería | Finanzas | Docente Universitario | Contabilidad Gerencial | Control de gestión | Mentor en Innovación Financiera
(已编辑)
举报内容
Imagina que vives en un país de primer mundo, tienes excedentes de capital y deseas invertirlo en un país emergente. ?Pondrías tu dinero en un país con crecimiento constante de su PIB y con Instituciones sólidas o lo harías en un país donde no hay respeto por la seguridad jurídica? La respuesta está en tu nivel de riesgo que estás dispuesto a asumir... Presumo que la gran mayoría escogerá el primer país.

已翻译

赞

Economics

+ 关注

给文章评分

我们借助人工智能创建了此文章。您认为这篇文章怎么样？

很棒不太好

举报此文章

查看全部

What are the most effective ways to measure macroeconomic policy success?

1

2

3

4

5

6

1 Growth and stability

2 Happiness and well-being

3 Efficiency and productivity

4 Institutions and governance

5 Trade-offs and challenges

6 Here’s what else to consider

Economics

给文章评分

感谢您的反馈

更多Economics相关文章

更多相关阅读内容

What are the most effective ways to measure macroeconomic policy success?

1

2

3

4

5

6

1 Growth and stability

2 Happiness and well-being

3 Efficiency and productivity

4 Institutions and governance

5 Trade-offs and challenges

6 Here’s what else to consider

Economics

给文章评分

感谢您的反馈

查看其他技能