登录查看更多内容

What do you do if your feedback in commercial design is causing more harm than good?

由人工智能和领英社区提供技术支持

Feedback in commercial design can be a double-edged sword. It's intended to refine and improve design work, but it can sometimes cause confusion, frustration, or even conflict. As a professional in the field of commercial design, which encompasses the creation of visuals for marketing and advertising purposes, you might find yourself in situations where the feedback you provide isn't yielding the results you expect. This article will guide you through a series of steps to handle such scenarios effectively, ensuring that your input contributes positively to the project's outcome.

此文章中的业界达人

由社区从 8 条内容中精选。了解更多

Romi Dey

User Experience ? One Design Community ? World Usability Day ? HCI International Conference ? IxDF
J. Patrício

Software Engineering com Pós Gradua??o na área da Seguran?a da informa??o, Hacker ético, Técnico na área de Projeto…
Mahmoud Abdelnaby

Multimedia Specialist | Video Editor & Motion Graphics | E-commerce & Digital Marketing | SEO & AI-Driven Content…

1 Reflect First

Before pointing fingers, take a moment to reflect on your feedback style. Could your communication be clearer? Have you been providing constructive criticism or just criticism? Your feedback should be specific, actionable, and accompanied by explanations that help the receiver understand the rationale behind your suggestions. Remember, your goal is to guide and improve the work, not to undermine confidence or creativity. If your feedback has been more destructive than constructive, it's time to reassess your approach and adjust your communication tactics.

添加您的观点

Romi Dey

User Experience ? One Design Community ? World Usability Day ? HCI International Conference ? IxDF
举报内容
When your design feedback feels destructive, take a step back. Assess if it's clear and specific. Vague comments leaves the designer lost. Instead, pinpoint why and offer suggestions. Open a dialogue. Discussing your concerns lets the designer explain their vision and brainstorm solutions together. Remember, the goal is a great final product, not micromanagement. Consider if your feedback aligns with the project's goals. Is it straying from the target audience or brand identity? Refocusing on these core elements can help ensure everyone's on the same page. By clarifying your feedback, fostering collaboration, and keeping goals in mind, you can turn potentially harmful critiques into positive steps towards a successful design.

已翻译

赞
Bilal iffi ??

Visual Designer at Systems Limited - Visual Design | UI UX | Motion Graphics | Post production
举报内容
According to me, if my feedback in commercial design is causing more harm than good, I would first reassess my approach to giving feedback. I would consider whether my feedback is constructive, specific, and delivered in a respectful manner. I would also seek feedback from others to understand how my feedback is being received and make adjustments accordingly.

已翻译

赞
J. Patrício

Software Engineering com Pós Gradua??o na área da Seguran?a da informa??o, Hacker ético, Técnico na área de Projeto com uso de ferramenta em Auto CAD, programador CNC Plasma.
举报内容
E fundamental Feedback mas temos que ser claro e as vezes saber ouvir, nem sempre somos os donos da Raz?o, o feedback quando bem direcionado só tem agregar valores.

已翻译

赞

2 Seek Clarity

If your feedback isn't having the desired effect, it's crucial to seek clarity. Misunderstanding can arise from both sides; therefore, engaging in a dialogue to ensure that your message is understood is key. Ask open-ended questions to gauge the receiver's perspective and be willing to listen to their responses. This can reveal if the issue is with the content of the feedback or its delivery. By fostering open communication, you can clear up any confusion and create a more collaborative environment.

添加您的观点

J. Patrício

Software Engineering com Pós Gradua??o na área da Seguran?a da informa??o, Hacker ético, Técnico na área de Projeto com uso de ferramenta em Auto CAD, programador CNC Plasma.
(已编辑)
举报内容
Muitas das vezes a forma de como nós, nos expressamos tem que ser a mas clara , o feedback para ser bem claro muitas das vezes temos que ser direto, caso n?o esteja sendo bem compreendido devemos para e ouvir também.

已翻译

赞

3 Adjust Approach

Adaptability is a vital skill in commercial design, especially when giving feedback. If your current method isn't working, consider adjusting your approach. Tailor your feedback to the individual's working style—some may prefer directness, while others thrive on detailed guidance. Additionally, focus on providing balanced feedback that includes positive reinforcement along with areas for improvement. This helps maintain morale and encourages a more receptive attitude towards constructive criticism.

添加您的观点

J. Patrício

Software Engineering com Pós Gradua??o na área da Seguran?a da informa??o, Hacker ético, Técnico na área de Projeto com uso de ferramenta em Auto CAD, programador CNC Plasma.
举报内容
A forma de como temos que agir muitas das vezes requer uma adapta??o seja ela, por conta de uma pergunta que nos fazem por n?o entender nossa comunica??o ou para melhor entendimento de todos.

已翻译

赞

4 Provide Examples

Sometimes words aren't enough, and this is where providing examples can be invaluable. Show visual references or sketches that illustrate your points. This can help bridge the gap between abstract concepts and practical application, making it easier for the designer to visualize what you're aiming for. Examples serve as a clear benchmark for quality and can often communicate your vision more effectively than descriptions alone.

添加您的观点

J. Patrício

Software Engineering com Pós Gradua??o na área da Seguran?a da informa??o, Hacker ético, Técnico na área de Projeto com uso de ferramenta em Auto CAD, programador CNC Plasma.
举报内容
Quando o feedback n?o está sendo muito Ben compreendido devemos nesse momento usar de outros meios para que possa vim ajudar.

已翻译

赞

5 Encourage Dialogue

Encouraging a two-way dialogue is critical when your feedback isn't producing the desired changes. Invite the design team to share their thoughts and concerns about your feedback. This exchange can foster mutual understanding and respect. It also allows designers to voice any challenges they're facing in implementing your suggestions, which can lead to collaborative problem-solving and more effective design solutions.

添加您的观点

6 Follow Up

Lastly, make sure to follow up on the feedback you've provided. Checking in on progress shows that you're invested in the outcome and willing to support the team through the revision process. It also gives you the opportunity to provide additional guidance if needed and to acknowledge improvements, reinforcing a positive feedback loop that benefits the entire project.

添加您的观点

7 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

添加您的观点

Mahmoud Abdelnaby

Multimedia Specialist | Video Editor & Motion Graphics | E-commerce & Digital Marketing | SEO & AI-Driven Content Creator
举报内容
Approach feedback like a gentle breeze, not a hurricane. Soften your blows, and you'll avoid extinguishing the creative flames. it's not about tearing down the tent; it's about raising the circus. Focus on constructive criticism and praise the acrobatics, even if they stumbled a bit. Positivity goes a long way in keeping the show running smoothly. Once, I critiqued a designer's work too harshly, and it felt like I sent a cannonball through their confidence. Instead of doubling down, I apologized and offered a helping hand. Together, we turned that stumble into a graceful leap. So, when giving feedback, be mindful of your words, offer support, and remember, we're all performers in this design circus.

已翻译

赞
Megha Agarwal

Founder and Principal Designer - MVA Interiors | Residential and Commercial Interior Designer | Corporate Designer | Boutique Design Consultant | Landscape Designer | Turnkey Projects | DM for Portfolio????????
举报内容
It depends from whom the feedback is coming. If it's from a genuine client or someone I know. I do think about it and take it seriously. But when you open a dialogue or something on a social platform the whole game changes. I use those feedback wisely because feedback is a kind of suggestion and I only take back home the ones I can resonate with. Sometimes it's not important to take every feedback seriously.. trust me.

已翻译

赞

Commercial Design

+ 关注

给文章评分

我们借助人工智能创建了此文章。您认为这篇文章怎么样？

很棒不太好

举报此文章

查看全部

What do you do if your feedback in commercial design is causing more harm than good?

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

1 Reflect First

2 Seek Clarity

3 Adjust Approach

4 Provide Examples

5 Encourage Dialogue

6 Follow Up

7 Here’s what else to consider

Commercial Design

给文章评分

感谢您的反馈

更多Commercial Design相关文章

更多相关阅读内容

What do you do if your feedback in commercial design is causing more harm than good?

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

1 Reflect First

2 Seek Clarity

3 Adjust Approach

4 Provide Examples

5 Encourage Dialogue

6 Follow Up

7 Here’s what else to consider

Commercial Design

给文章评分

感谢您的反馈

查看其他技能