What do you do if logical reasoning isn't working in your level design and puzzle creation?

1 Embrace Intuition

Sometimes the best solution is to step away from rigid logical structures and trust your intuition. Consider how the level or puzzle makes you feel rather than strictly how it functions. Intuitive design can lead to innovative gameplay experiences that surprise and delight players. If a puzzle seems too complex, simplify it based on what feels right. Remember, the goal is to create a fun and memorable game, not to solve a math problem. Letting your instincts guide you can often lead to breakthroughs that pure logic cannot.

2 Study Classics

If logical reasoning has hit a wall, turn to classic games for inspiration. These titles have withstood the test of time for a reason. Analyze how they balance challenge and enjoyment, how they introduce and build upon game mechanics, and how they guide the player through levels. You might discover an approach or a mechanic that you can adapt to your current design challenge. Learning from the masters is an age-old practice that can provide fresh insights into your work.

3 Player Perspective

Shift your focus to the player's perspective. Sometimes designers get so wrapped up in their logic and systems that they forget about the player's experience. Playtest your levels or puzzles with people who have varying degrees of gaming experience. Observe where they struggle or lose interest. Their feedback can provide valuable insights that logical reasoning alone might not reveal. It's crucial to ensure that the challenge is fair and enjoyable from the player's viewpoint.

5 Iterate Designs

When logic fails, iteration is your friend. Take your existing level or puzzle and make small, incremental changes rather than sweeping overhauls. Adjust one variable at a time and see how it impacts the overall design. Through trial and error, you might stumble upon a solution that feels right and works within the game's world. Iterative design allows for flexibility and can lead to innovative solutions that a rigid logical approach might miss.

6 Consult Peers

Lastly, don't hesitate to consult with fellow game designers or even friends who might offer a fresh perspective. A problem shared can often be a problem halved. Other designers might have faced similar challenges and can provide advice or solutions that you haven't considered. Collaboration can be a powerful tool in overcoming design hurdles that seem insurmountable when faced alone.

7 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?