登录查看更多内容

Last updated on 2024年8月25日

全部

How would you handle a scenario where an actor is resistant to following the director's vision?

由人工智能和领英社区提供技术支持

Navigating creative differences in film can be as complex as the productions themselves. When an actor is resistant to a director's vision, it's a delicate situation that demands finesse. As a director, your primary role is to guide the project to fruition while balancing the contributions of your cast and crew. But what do you do when one of your key players isn't on board with your direction? Understanding how to handle such a scenario is crucial for maintaining the integrity of the film and ensuring a collaborative and respectful environment on set.

此文章中的业界达人

由社区从 9 条内容中精选。了解更多

Leslie Brown

3 个答复
Ranelle Golden

Award-winning Screenwriter, Director and Producer

1 个答复

1 Open Dialogue

Initiating an open and respectful dialogue is the first step in addressing resistance from an actor . It's essential to understand their perspective and concerns. Listen actively and validate their feelings, showing that you respect their artistic process. Sometimes, resistance stems from a lack of clarity or understanding of the character's motivations. By discussing the character's backstory, goals, and emotional arc, you can help the actor align with your vision. This collaborative approach can foster trust and potentially lead to a breakthrough in the actor's performance.

添加您的观点

Leslie Brown
举报内容
Resistance to following the direction given can sometimes be rooted in the actor's training background. I've seen actors that have rehearsed and rehearsed a scene or character so much they become unwilling or unable to make changes. Yes, discussion and dialogue can move the needle. But in at least one instance I've seen an actor lose out on a role, because they couldn't adjust when called upon to do so. Sometimes the director's vision isn't always obvious when filming a scene. And if as an actor you don't really "get" it, then it's up to you to trust the director. After all, it's their film. Sometimes in the audition process even after a great interpretation I'll re-direct an actor, just to make sure they ARE in fact "direct-able".

已翻译

赞
Chaz Presley

Writer - Director - Producer
举报内容
The key to any working relationship is communication and curiosity. I am very upfront with every member of my crew from acting to production assistants, keeping an on going dialogue is goal. I relate to the saying if your sweat more in times of peace your bleed less in times of conflict. Working with newer acting talent you may only have a sample of what they are capable of. Finding that connecting thread even if small can weave and develop into something amazing. Trust goes both ways, I am trusting the actor with my vision or material and they are trusting me with their vulnerability and capturing their very best out of them

已翻译

赞
Tim Chessman

Actor/Voice Actor with Crown North Talent Agency, San Francisco Bay Area & Los Angeles, CA/Idiom Talent Hollywood/Voquent London/Writer/2024 Denver Film Fest Award-Winning Cast & Crew/imdb.me/TimChessman??????
举报内容
A healthy way to look at this, I think, is to accept the idea that, as actors, we’re here to follow the director’s vision. If it’s not exactly in line with what we’re doing, we can of course discuss it, but in the end it’s the director who steers the ship. Plus, if we make them happy and do a good job for them, they’re more likely to use us again or provide us with a positive referral. This has happened to me several times as well as to many other actors I’ve known.

已翻译

赞

2 Flexibility Counts

Flexibility can be a valuable tool when dealing with resistance. While maintaining the overall vision for the film, consider the actor's input as potentially enriching the project. They may offer insights into their character that you hadn't considered. By being open to adjustments, you can find a middle ground that satisfies both the directorial vision and the actor's creative impulses . This doesn't mean compromising the story's integrity but rather adapting to incorporate new ideas that enhance the narrative.

添加您的观点

加载更多内容

3 Rehearse Together

Rehearsal is a critical time for experimentation and addressing concerns. Use this period to explore different interpretations of the character and scenes with the actor. This hands-on approach can help them feel more connected to the material and could lead to a compromise that serves the film's best interests. It's also an opportunity for other cast members to weigh in, providing a broader perspective that might resonate with the resistant actor and help them understand the director's vision more clearly.

添加您的观点

Chaz Presley

Writer - Director - Producer
举报内容
I am huge supporter of Filmmakers should know all the parts of their film. It helps that I did acting and stage performances in college, but leading from the front or side is how actors really get to see how you are. It doesn't have to be perfect but reading lines or walking through choreography with actors helps immensely engage the crew in creative energy.

已翻译

赞

4 Support Systems

Sometimes an actor's resistance can be mitigated by leveraging support systems within the production . This could involve bringing in an acting coach who can bridge the gap between the actor's method and the director's expectations. Additionally, other cast members who are supportive of the director's vision can influence their peer through camaraderie and shared purpose. The key is to create an environment where the actor does not feel isolated but part of a cohesive team working towards a common goal.

添加您的观点

5 Creative Compromise

Finding a creative compromise is often the most practical resolution. This involves negotiating certain aspects of the performance that are important to the actor while still keeping the core of the director's vision intact. It's about give-and-take, where both parties make concessions to achieve a result that satisfies the artistic needs of the film. Remember, filmmaking is inherently collaborative, and sometimes the best results come from unexpected compromises.

添加您的观点

Chaz Presley

Writer - Director - Producer
举报内容
We have to compromise so much in this industry, so often things move from a snails pace then you blink and you are on set and your burning daylight so you may have to make creative changes to stay on schedule. This also includes an actors performance, I see this happen the most toward the end of production when an actor really feels character would do something differently. I treat this very delicately since this actor has invested themselves in to this character and I have seen where they are drawing from very personal places. You have to have an open mind and talk something out, because they may have uncovered something that your BIGGER PICTURE mindset might have overlooked.

已翻译

赞

6 Maintain Respect

Throughout this process, it's imperative to maintain respect for all involved parties. A director should never resort to authoritarian tactics or dismiss an actor's creative input. Mutual respect fosters a positive working environment and can lead to more authentic performances. Even when disagreements arise, addressing them professionally and courteously can prevent escalation and preserve the working relationship for current and future projects.

添加您的观点

7 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

添加您的观点

Ranelle Golden

Award-winning Screenwriter, Director and Producer
举报内容
As a Director I put them through their paces in auditions and call backs. But that doesn't always mean the actor won't read the full script and come up with their own vision of the character they are tasked with bringing to life. First, I find out why, privately. I see if we can reach a compromise on things that will allow them to make it their own but keep the full vision intact. Often the actor may bring something to the character that is simply brilliant. That being said if they remain resistant to Direction, and it compromises the vision of the project - then they have to be replaced. This causes a delay but it's for the good of the film. Shift schedules to keep production going and recast.

已翻译

赞
Ian Coyne

Producer at Atomic Arts
举报内容
This should be sorted out in the casting process and should never make it to set. It’s really important as a director to make sure that you have people who understand and share your vision and as a producer it’s my job to be the last line of defense if it isn’t. This is the rare case where I may intervene to try and influence the director to go with more appropriate casting. I try not to intervene often but this would be one exception.

已翻译

赞
Colette B.

Screenwriter (Non-Union)??Business Bard ??Creative Strategist
举报内容
I love actors with all my heart but they are not hired to be "resistant"- that stance creates confusion and production delays. Actors have the chance to read the script and therefore refuse the part or express concerns PRIOR to taking the part. It's very disrespectful to the Director to become combative once filming starts.

已翻译

赞

Film Industry

+ 关注

给文章评分

我们借助人工智能创建了此文章。您认为这篇文章怎么样？

很棒不太好

举报此文章

How would you handle a scenario where an actor is resistant to following the director's vision?

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

1 Open Dialogue

2 Flexibility Counts

3 Rehearse Together

4 Support Systems

5 Creative Compromise

6 Maintain Respect

7 Here’s what else to consider

Film Industry

给文章评分

感谢您的反馈

更多Film Industry相关文章

更多相关阅读内容