How do you assess the value of your electrical design for automation and control systems?

Assessing the value of an electrical design for automation and control systems involves a thorough evaluation of its cost-effectiveness, performance, reliability, scalability, compliance with safety and regulatory standards, ease of maintenance, and potential for long-term cost savings and return on investment. It requires a holistic approach that considers both initial investment and long-term operational benefits to determine its overall value to the project and organization.

I agree but we should also consider the constraints and limitations in the process that you are designing for. These aspects of view helps to sketch the issue and the path of receiving its solution.

THE AUTOMATION SYSTEM IS SOLELY BASED ON ELECTRICAL SYSTEM DESIGN. THE PERFORMANCE OF AUTOMATION DEPENDS ON THE SWITCHING ACCURACY AND PID VALUE OF CONTROLLERS. THE PERFORMANCE OF AUTOMATION IS 100% ELECTRICAL PERFORMANCE.

Let's consider the following steps: 1. Functionality and Efficiency: Evaluate how well the design meets the functional requirements and how efficiently it operates in automating and controlling processes. 2. Reliability and Safety: Consider the reliability and safety aspects to ensure the design functions without failures and adheres to safety standards. 3. Cost-effectiveness: Assess the cost of implementation and operation versus the benefits gained from improved automation and control. 4. Scalability and Flexibility: Determine how easily the design can adapt to changes in system requirements or expansions in the future. 5. Integration Capability: Evaluate how well the design integrates with existing systems and other technologies.

Both are interlinked in quite way. Like when you are starting a motor , control system design should properly control whether it will be dol or soft starter or a vfd. What are feedback we are taking from Electrical System and same time how the control will be better and smooth for large drive system.

I do agree and to achieve this goal first of all you should evaluate your idea or proposed method or design by means of its simulation. Then, based on its results and via some indices you can have a reliable assessment.

An additional metric is Complexity. In design context, complexity could refer to configuration, components, wiring..etc. A complex design is more prone to malfunction, harder to understand and hence difficult to adapt, modify, troubleshoot, and improve. Having a simple electrical design that can be easily understood is of a great value to any client. It can be easily changed to meet new requirements, hence a better flexibility. It can be scaled up or down, hence a better scalability.

By conducting a comprehensive performance evaluation, you not only quantify the impact of your electrical design but also create a foundation for continuous enhancement and optimization, ensuring that it consistently aligns with the system's evolving needs and expectations

Evaluating the performance of electrical engineering involves assessing the effectiveness, efficiency, and reliability of electrical systems, equipment, and processes. This evaluation is crucial to ensure that electrical engineering solutions meet their intended objectives and function optimally. Here are key steps and considerations for evaluating the performance of electrical engineering: Set Clear Performance Metrics, These metrics should align with the objectives and requirements defined during the design phase. Data Collection, Testing and Simulation, Reliability Analysis, Energy Efficiency, Safety Compliance, Operational Efficiency, Maintenance and Reliability, Cost-Benefit Analysis

ENGINEERING IS OPTIMIZATION. ELECTRICAL DESIGN IS BASED ON THE TECHNICAL AND FINACIAL PERFORMANCE RATED PER YEAR. SO YOU DO NOT NEED TO ASK THIS KIND OF UNNECESSARY QUESTIONS.

Try to find the best ROI electrical design is not a trivial thing. Something to consider also is selecting components with an extensive live expectation rather than cheat almost obsolete devices

One thing I have found helpful is to keep in mind that a cost effective project requires ongoing attention and adaptation as project circumstances evolve

In addition to written items , the simplicity of design is important . Complicated designs may be subject to malfunction.So, goal oriented,reliable , safety, cost effective and simplicity are the main factors for a good design.

Based on nation, region, government schemes, accessories and equipment discount, Tax, ROI, labour cost, and terms and conditions.

An important aspect in electrical design is identifying Single Points of Failure. These are points where failure of which would lead to collapse or failure of the entire system. While it might be easy to identify single points of failure, mitigating their risk is rather tricky. When dealing with such an issue, one should take into account the probability and frequency of occurrence of such a failure, along with its criticality. We can’t just keep adding backup system/ device for every single point of failure.

Assessing the value of electrical design in automation involves addressing risks. Identifying potential system vulnerabilities, reliability issues, or safety concerns is crucial. Mitigating risks ensures robustness, reliability, and compliance, ultimately enhancing the design's value in delivering safe and effective automation and control systems.

As a Certified Machinery Safety Expert I will focus on what would be the performance level of the system them design the safety system accordingly. As an Electrical Designer I would add method like redundancy and diversity to mitigate to enhance the reliability of the overall system. So examples are: Redundant PLC systems. Keep essential part in stock to reduce down time. Performance a well structured Preventive Maintenance

This step should be happening in parallel to the efficiency evaluation, since you can't reach the most efficient system without considering safety requirements.

Risk identification, Risk management, Risk analysis report, fault and failure chances, Documentation, lab reports, certification, and robust system design.

Having an open mind and accepting constructive criticism is part of the engineering journey. Be able to have access to the opinion of people without different points of view would be essential to the continuous improvement of the electrical system

Having the feedback is one the important factors to evaluate effectiveness of the design. Well prepared periodic questionnaires sent to clients are essential. Questionnaires must be comprehensive and written in a simple way and also cover important fields of the design.

In my experience it’s a good idea to get the right team together from inception. The team will evolve through the process. By having the right people in the right places it keeps the last minute critiques positive. When tough criticism comes , think before you speak. Keep it positive.

Kick off meetings, feedback, communication, new innovative ideas, easy to understand, focus on the goal, flexibility, cost-effective, prioritized, and user interface.

Assessing the value of electrical designs for automation involves incorporating feedback. Feedback aids in gauging system efficiency, identifying flaws, and enhancing functionality. By integrating user insights and industry expertise, adjustments can be made, ensuring the design aligns with user needs, enhances performance, and ultimately delivers optimal value in automation and control systems.

Understand our client’s needs, document report, visualization, function, presentation, benefits, practical and theoretical approach, clear communication, story-line, scope of work, transparency, simulation, and reports.

After electrical load survey many type of building, I can make electrical design on a plane with proper size of cable and loads distribution with protection system. Then make an quantity of estimate on demand of quality work based for clients costing setups.If Substations are need, I can design, estimate and supervision that all are cost-effective way.

User-friendly design in hardware & software perspectives adds value to automation and control system. Keep user in mind in design process to ensure human and machine integrate seamlessly during system operation lifecycle!

The value of electrical design for automation and control lies in its ability to enhance efficiency, safety, and reliability while minimizing costs and ensuring compliance with standards and regulations.

These three things look like simple, but they come with many challenges, problems, cost and efficiency. DTO (Design to order), DTD (Design to Development) & FDD (Final Design Development)