How can you choose between issuing equity or debt?

1 Equity Offering

An equity offering is when a company sells new shares to investors, either in the primary market or in the secondary market. The main benefit of issuing equity is that it does not increase the company's debt burden or interest payments, and it can signal confidence and growth potential to the market. However, issuing equity also has some drawbacks, such as diluting the existing shareholders' ownership and earnings per share, exposing the company to market volatility and price fluctuations, and incurring high issuance costs and regulatory requirements.

2 Debt Offering

A debt offering is when a company borrows money from lenders, either by issuing bonds or taking loans. The main advantage of issuing debt is that it preserves the existing shareholders' control and claim on the company's assets and profits, and it can provide tax benefits by reducing the taxable income. Moreover, issuing debt can be cheaper and faster than issuing equity, and it can allow the company to leverage its assets and increase its return on equity. However, issuing debt also has some risks, such as increasing the company's financial leverage and default risk, creating fixed obligations and covenants that limit the company's flexibility and cash flow, and exposing the company to interest rate and credit risk.

3 Trade-offs and Criteria

When deciding between equity and debt offerings, there are various trade-offs and criteria to consider, which depend on the company's situation and objectives. The cost of capital is a key factor, as equity is typically more expensive than debt due to the higher return required by equity investors for the additional risk. Additionally, the availability of capital should be taken into account, as equity may be more accessible for start-ups or high-growth companies, while debt may be more available for mature or stable companies. Furthermore, the impact on valuation should be considered, as issuing equity can dilute existing shareholders' stake and reduce earnings per share, while issuing debt can increase risk and reduce cash flow available to shareholders. Lastly, the strategic goals should be aligned with the capital structure; for example, issuing equity can be more suitable for companies that want to pursue growth opportunities, while issuing debt can be more appropriate for companies that want to optimize their capital efficiency.

5 Tips and Advice

As an investment banker, it is important to analyze the pros and cons of equity and debt offerings, and recommend the best option for your clients. To do this effectively, you must assess the company's current and projected financial performance, cash flow, leverage, profitability, and growth rate. Additionally, you should monitor the market trends, sentiments, demand, and supply for different types of capital to identify the best timing and pricing for the offering. Moreover, you need to calculate and compare the cost of capital, availability of capital, impact on valuation, and strategic goals for each possible capital structure. Finally, you must present and explain your analysis and recommendation to the company's management and board to highlight the rationale and benefits of choosing equity or debt over the other.

6 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?