How can businesses use cognitive dissonance to influence consumer behavior?

1 What is cognitive dissonance theory?

Cognitive dissonance theory was proposed by Leon Festinger in 1957, based on his observation of a cult that predicted the end of the world. When the prophecy failed, the cult members did not abandon their beliefs, but instead rationalized them by claiming that their faith had saved the world. Festinger argued that people strive to maintain consistency between their cognitions, which are the mental representations of their knowledge, beliefs, attitudes, and behaviors. When there is inconsistency or discrepancy between them, people experience cognitive dissonance, which motivates them to reduce or resolve it. There are four main ways to do so: changing one or more of the cognitions, adding new cognitions, minimizing the importance of the cognitions, or seeking support from others who share the same cognitions.

2 How does cognitive dissonance affect consumer behavior?

Cognitive dissonance can affect consumer behavior in different stages of the buying process, such as before, during, and after the purchase. For example, before the purchase, a consumer may experience dissonance when they have to choose between two or more attractive alternatives, such as different brands, models, or features. This can lead to decision paralysis, regret, or dissatisfaction. To reduce the dissonance, the consumer may seek more information, compare the alternatives, or rely on social proof or recommendations. During the purchase, a consumer may experience dissonance when they have to pay a high price, give up a benefit, or face a risk. This can lead to hesitation, anxiety, or guilt. To reduce the dissonance, the consumer may justify the purchase by focusing on the positive aspects, creating a sense of urgency, or feeling rewarded or gratified. After the purchase, a consumer may experience dissonance when they encounter new information, feedback, or alternatives that contradict their choice. This can lead to post-purchase rationalization, cognitive loyalty, or attitude change. To reduce the dissonance, the consumer may confirm their choice by highlighting the benefits, ignoring the drawbacks, or avoiding the alternatives.

3 How can businesses use cognitive dissonance to persuade customers?

Businesses can use cognitive dissonance to persuade customers by creating or amplifying the dissonance between their current and desired states, and then offering a solution that can resolve it. For example, a business can create dissonance by highlighting a problem, need, or gap the customer has and then presenting their product or service as the best way to solve it. Alternatively, they can emphasize the consequences, costs, or risks of not choosing their product or service, and then show how it can prevent or reduce them. To create or amplify cognitive dissonance, businesses can use techniques such as social proof, testimonials, and endorsements to demonstrate how others have benefited from their product or service; scarcity and limited-time offers to create urgency; contrast and comparison to highlight the differences of their product over alternatives; and reciprocity, commitment, and consistency to induce customers to feel obliged.

4 How can businesses use cognitive dissonance to retain customers?

Businesses can use cognitive dissonance to retain customers by reducing or preventing the dissonance that may arise after the purchase, and then reinforcing the customer's satisfaction, loyalty, or advocacy. For instance, post-purchase support, feedback, or reassurance can reduce dissonance and incentivizing customers with discounts or recognition can reward them. Alternately, businesses can prevent dissonance by minimizing the exposure of alternatives and reminding customers of the benefits of their product or service. To reduce or prevent cognitive dissonance, businesses should provide after-sales service, follow-up, or warranty; solicit feedback, reviews, or referrals; offer loyalty programs, membership benefits, or repeat purchase incentives; and create a brand community, identity, or story.

5 How can businesses avoid creating negative dissonance?

Businesses should be honest, ethical, and consistent in their marketing and communication to avoid creating negative dissonance that can damage their reputation and sales. Negative dissonance can occur when a business makes false, exaggerated, or misleading claims that do not match the reality of their product or service, leading to customer dissatisfaction. To avoid this, businesses should provide accurate, relevant, and complete information about their product or service and not exaggerate, omit, or hide any facts. They should also deliver on their promises, expectations, and standards without overpromising or underdelivering. Additionally, businesses should admit and correct any mistakes or errors while respecting and protecting the customer's privacy. Finally, businesses should avoid spamming, harassing, or exploiting any data or consent.

6 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?