First, try to get on the same page about your game's target audience, mood, and brand identity. Then have a feedback session where each team member shares why the colors resonate with them for their project, which may reveal common themes. Create a few mood boards or sample scenes with different palettes that incorporate these common elements. If possible, test these options with players or stakeholders. With collaborative feedback and a foundation in the game's goals, you can choose a palette that feels cohesive and has team-wide support.

Open Communication Allowing your team members to express their concerns or feelings towards any aspect of the game is important. Their feedback should be welcomed. BUT A critical decision like the color palette falls under the art director's jurisdiction. Yes, it is great to listen to feedback, and sure, you can focus test it. However, there is most likely an expert on your team who is accountable for this. Live to Fight Another Day Disagreeing on an aspect of the game and expressing your opinions is healthy. But once the accountable party who was hired for this exact reason has made a decision, it’s time to move forward. Do Not Make global sweeping calls like this via a committee or voting system. Trust the vision holder.

I approach it by gathering everyone's input and understanding the reasons behind their preferences. I'll focus on how the palette aligns with the game's theme, mood, and target audience. Then, I'll propose creating mockups or variations that incorporate key elements from everyone's ideas. Testing these options with players or stakeholders can provide objective feedback, helping us make a data-driven decision. Ultimately, I'll remind the team that the goal is to enhance the player's experience, guiding us to a compromise that balances creative vision with practicality.

You cannot satisfy everyone, and that is simply a fact. The crucial question is: why should we even try? A color palette is an essential part of a game's aesthetics. What is the game about? What feelings do we want to convey? The answers to these questions will guide us in choosing the appropriate color palette. Therefore, we must first clarify the game's concept and then consider which color palette the players will appreciate for it.