登录查看更多内容

Last updated on 2024年8月14日

Your design team is obsessed with aesthetics. How do you convince them that structural integrity is crucial?

由人工智能和领英社区提供技术支持

When your design team prioritizes aesthetics over everything else, it's crucial to remind them that without structural integrity, no amount of beauty will save a building from failure. As a civil engineer, your role extends beyond just creating visually pleasing structures; you must ensure that buildings are safe, functional, and durable. Convincing your team to strike a balance between form and function is not just important—it's a professional obligation.

此文章中的业界达人

由社区从 4 条内容中精选。了解更多

Carmelo Arquiza

Methods Drafter

1 Aesthetic vs. Safety

While a visually stunning design can capture the imagination, it's the unseen strength of a structure that truly matters. You must communicate to your team that a building's beauty is short-lived if its integrity is compromised. Explain that structural integrity ensures the safety of occupants and longevity of the structure, which is the ultimate goal of civil engineering design. Emphasize that while aesthetics contribute to a structure's appeal, they should never overshadow the fundamental engineering principles that keep it standing.

添加您的观点

Carmelo Arquiza

Methods Drafter
举报内容
Safety is the number one priority, as the imaginative objective to solve how the aesthetic will be built will be an engineering uniqueness to solve the problem given that you are the civil engineer to deliver the design. A civil engineering designer is clever enough to know what is supposed to be done and to provide a much clearer explanation of what will happen and the consequences of a failed design, particularly regarding its impact on the project's durability over time. Both safety and aesthetics are surely needed, and by not dominating each other, they should complement each other to satisfy both design goals and impress everyone who sees their work.

已翻译

赞

2 Functionality Focus

Emphasize to your team that a building must first and foremost serve its intended purpose effectively. Aesthetic elements should enhance, not hinder, the functionality of the space. For instance, the flow of human traffic, the comfort of the occupants, and the building's energy efficiency are all aspects that should not be sacrificed for visual flair. Encourage your team to view design through the lens of practicality, ensuring that the structure meets the needs of its users while maintaining its visual appeal.

添加您的观点

3 Engineering Ethics

Ethics in civil engineering dictate that public safety, welfare, and environmental stewardship take precedence over aesthetic considerations. Remind your team that as civil engineers, they have a responsibility to uphold these ethical standards. The consequences of neglecting structural integrity can be dire, including potential loss of life and environmental harm. Instilling a sense of ethical duty can help shift the focus from purely aesthetic goals to designs that are both beautiful and responsible.

添加您的观点

Luis Felipe Martínez Mateo

Director de proyectos en DDCI, Dise?o y Desarrollo de Ciudades Inteligentes; empresa integrante de Grupo Tort
举报内容
La ética puede llegar a ser controvertida en un entorno donde factores adicionales sean considerados prioritarios, como el costo o, en este caso, la estética. Sin embargo, el mantener siempre presente la finalidad de un abordaje de ingeniería en un proyecto es algo esencial, dar seguridad. Los ingenieros deben tener la acertividad y criterios para aprobar o desechar propuestas que beneficien o saboteen el correcto desarrollo de un proyecto; y los demás interesados deben tener la confianza y flexibilidad para abordar dichos temas, buscando las respuestas que garanticen seguridad para los usuarios. La constante capacitación, estudio y especialización es una estrategia que fortalece estos aspectos, tanto individual como colectivamente.

已翻译

赞

4 Risk Management

Discussing the risks associated with neglecting structural integrity can be a powerful motivator. Describe scenarios where aesthetic-driven designs failed to meet safety standards, leading to structural failures and financial losses. Highlight that risk management is a key component of civil engineering design, and that by prioritizing structural integrity, the team is not only ensuring safety but also protecting the investment made in the project.

添加您的观点

Carmelo Arquiza

Methods Drafter
举报内容
The risks behind the argument between aesthetics and safety are very real. If anyone cuts corners just for the sake of making it economically cheap, it often doesn't provide a true solution to the problem. The implications can be too much on the loss side. An intensive study to understand the real purpose of the design and what we are aiming for should be the most relevant way to manage this risk in any architectural (be realistic) and engineering (be your worth) projects. Proving to every participant what they are supposed to do in handling this risk is crucial, not just arguing but finding solutions to make it work.

已翻译

赞

5 Collaborative Approach

Encourage a collaborative approach where architects and engineers work together from the outset. This integration allows for a harmonious balance between aesthetics and structural integrity. By involving engineers early in the design process, aesthetic ambitions can be aligned with practical engineering solutions. This collaboration ensures that the structure is both visually appealing and technically sound.

添加您的观点

6 Educate and Inspire

Lastly, consider using education as a tool to inspire your team about the elegance of structural solutions. Present case studies of iconic structures where form and function are seamlessly integrated. Show how innovative engineering has enabled breathtaking designs that also stand the test of time. By celebrating these achievements, you can demonstrate that aesthetics and structural integrity are not mutually exclusive but can coexist to create truly inspiring architecture.

添加您的观点

Carmelo Arquiza

Methods Drafter
举报内容
An iconic project creation always comes from a team that builds with their expertise to make the project a reality without a doubt, with both aesthetics and safety working together to achieve this. Aesthetic and safety are bound together as one to make the project a reality. This synergy highlights the team's success, allowing their good and excellent work, expertise experiences achievements, and integrity to be appreciated as the true solution to any problem for both.

已翻译

赞

Civil Engineering Design

+ 关注

给文章评分

我们借助人工智能创建了此文章。您认为这篇文章怎么样？

很棒不太好

举报此文章

查看全部

Your design team is obsessed with aesthetics. How do you convince them that structural integrity is crucial?

1

2

3

4

5

6

1 Aesthetic vs. Safety

2 Functionality Focus

3 Engineering Ethics

4 Risk Management

5 Collaborative Approach

6 Educate and Inspire

Civil Engineering Design

给文章评分

感谢您的反馈

更多Civil Engineering Design相关文章

更多相关阅读内容

Your design team is obsessed with aesthetics. How do you convince them that structural integrity is crucial?

1

2

3

4

5

6

1 Aesthetic vs. Safety

2 Functionality Focus

3 Engineering Ethics

4 Risk Management

5 Collaborative Approach

6 Educate and Inspire

Civil Engineering Design

给文章评分

感谢您的反馈

查看其他技能