What are some challenges and best practices for testing game mechanics and immersion?

由人工智能和领英社区提供技术支持

Game mechanics are the rules and systems that govern how players interact with a game and how the game responds to their actions. Immersion is the degree to which players feel engaged and connected with the game world and its characters. Testing game mechanics and immersion is a crucial part of game development, as it can reveal how well the game achieves its intended goals, how fun and satisfying it is to play, and how it can be improved. However, testing game mechanics and immersion also poses some challenges and requires some best practices to ensure valid and useful results. In this article, we will explore some of these challenges and best practices, and how they can help you create better games.

在这篇协作文章中查找专家回答

由社区从 3 条内容中精选。了解更多

1 Challenge 1: Defining and measuring immersion

One of the main challenges of testing game mechanics and immersion is defining and measuring what immersion actually means. Immersion is a subjective and multidimensional experience that can vary depending on the player, the game, and the context. Some aspects of immersion include emotional involvement, cognitive engagement, spatial presence, narrative involvement, and social interaction. However, there is no universal agreement on how to define and measure these aspects, and different methods may have different advantages and limitations. For example, surveys and interviews can capture players' self-reported perceptions and feelings, but they may also interrupt the flow of the game and introduce biases. Physiological and behavioral measures can provide more objective and continuous data, but they may also be influenced by external factors and require more sophisticated equipment and analysis.

添加您的观点

Maurício Piccini

Programador com Doutorado em Literatura
举报内容
Uma forma prática de medir a imers?o, utilizando um jogo de plataforma como exemplo, seria analisar o qu?o o jogador se conecta com a história da personagem principal: Medi??o: Observar e quantificar o tempo que o jogador passa explorando áreas opcionais do jogo que expandem a história da personagem, mas n?o oferecem recompensas diretas em termos de jogabilidade, como novos itens ou poderes. Análise: Jogadores que dedicam mais tempo a essas áreas opcionais demonstram maior interesse pela narrativa e conex?o com a personagem, indicando um nível mais alto de imers?o. Essa análise pode ser combinada com outras métricas, como questionários pós-jogo sobre a história e a personagem, para uma vis?o mais completa.

已翻译

赞

2 Best practice 1: Choosing appropriate methods and metrics

To overcome the challenge of defining and measuring immersion, you need to choose appropriate methods and metrics that suit your game and your testing goals. You should consider the following factors when choosing your methods and metrics: the type and level of immersion you want to achieve, the target audience and their preferences, the game genre and mechanics, the testing environment and resources, and the research questions and hypotheses you want to test. You should also use multiple methods and metrics to triangulate your data and increase your validity and reliability. For example, you can combine surveys and interviews with physiological and behavioral measures, or use different types of surveys and interviews to capture different dimensions of immersion.

添加您的观点

3 Challenge 2: Balancing realism and abstraction

Another challenge of testing game mechanics and immersion is balancing realism and abstraction . Realism refers to how closely the game mimics the real world or a fictional world, while abstraction refers to how the game simplifies or stylizes certain elements or aspects. Both realism and abstraction can affect immersion, depending on the game and the player. For example, realism can enhance immersion by creating a sense of presence and authenticity, but it can also reduce immersion by creating a sense of uncanny valley or cognitive dissonance. Abstraction can enhance immersion by creating a sense of aesthetics and expression, but it can also reduce immersion by creating a sense of detachment or confusion.

添加您的观点

Maurício Piccini

Programador com Doutorado em Literatura
举报内容
Um exemplo prático da influência do realismo e da abstra??o na imers?o é o sistema de crafting em jogos de RPG. Um jogo realista poderia exigir que o jogador reunisse materiais específicos e os combinasse em uma ordem precisa, simulando um processo complexo de manufatura. Isso pode aumentar a imers?o para alguns, mas tornar o jogo tedioso para outros. Já um jogo abstrato poderia simplificar o crafting, permitindo que o jogador combine poucos itens básicos de forma intuitiva para criar itens poderosos. Essa abstra??o pode tornar o jogo mais fluido e divertido, sem sacrificar a imers?o na progress?o do personagem. A chave é encontrar o equilíbrio certo para o público-alvo e o gênero do jogo.

已翻译

赞

4 Best practice 2: Aligning realism and abstraction with game design

To overcome the challenge of balancing realism and abstraction, you need to align them with your game design and your intended immersion effect. You should consider the following factors when aligning realism and abstraction: the theme and tone of your game, the expectations and motivations of your players, the feedback and affordances of your game mechanics, and the coherence and consistency of your game world. You should also test your game with different levels of realism and abstraction to see how they affect immersion and player satisfaction. For example, you can test your game with different graphics, sounds, physics, animations, interfaces, or narratives, and compare how they influence immersion.

添加您的观点

5 Challenge 3: Accounting for player agency and diversity

A third challenge of testing game mechanics and immersion is accounting for player agency and diversity. Player agency refers to the degree of choice and control that players have over their actions and outcomes in the game. Player diversity refers to the differences among players in terms of their backgrounds, preferences, skills, styles, personalities, and goals. Both player agency and diversity can affect immersion, depending on the game and the situation. For example, player agency can enhance immersion by creating a sense of empowerment and ownership, but it can also reduce immersion by creating a sense of overload or frustration. Player diversity can enhance immersion by creating a sense of personalization and identification, but it can also reduce immersion by creating a sense of alienation or conflict.

添加您的观点

Maurício Piccini

Programador com Doutorado em Literatura
举报内容
Um exemplo prático para balancear a agência do jogador com a imers?o em um jogo com diferentes estilos de jogo é oferecer caminhos múltiplos para progress?o. Imagine um RPG onde o jogador pode escolher entre diplomacia, furtividade ou combate para superar desafios. ? Jogadores diplomáticos podem persuadir NPCs, descobrir informa??es secretas e evitar conflitos. ? Jogadores furtivos podem usar o ambiente a seu favor, desvendar passagens secretas e eliminar inimigos silenciosamente. ? Jogadores combatentes podem usar uma variedade de armas e habilidades para superar os inimigos em confrontos diretos.

已翻译

赞

6 Best practice 3: Adapting to player agency and diversity

To overcome the challenge of accounting for player agency and diversity, you need to adapt your game mechanics and immersion strategies to suit different players and situations. You should consider the following factors when adapting to player agency and diversity: the balance and trade-off between freedom and guidance, the options and consequences of player actions, the feedback and rewards of player outcomes, the accessibility and usability of your game mechanics, and the representation and inclusion of your game characters and stories. You should also test your game with different types of players and scenarios to see how they affect immersion and player satisfaction. For example, you can test your game with different difficulty levels, modes, paths, endings, or customization options, and compare how they influence immersion.

添加您的观点

Game Mechanics

+ 关注

给文章评分

我们借助人工智能创建了此文章。您认为这篇文章怎么样？

很棒不太好

举报此文章

查看全部

What are some challenges and best practices for testing game mechanics and immersion?

1

2

3

4

5

6

1 Challenge 1: Defining and measuring immersion

2 Best practice 1: Choosing appropriate methods and metrics

3 Challenge 2: Balancing realism and abstraction

4 Best practice 2: Aligning realism and abstraction with game design

5 Challenge 3: Accounting for player agency and diversity

6 Best practice 3: Adapting to player agency and diversity

Game Mechanics

给文章评分

感谢您的反馈

更多Game Mechanics相关文章

更多相关阅读内容