What are the pros and cons of using peer-to-peer payment services versus traditional bank transfers?

1 How P2P payment services work

P2P payment services use electronic funds transfer (EFT), which is a process of moving money electronically from one account to another. EFT can include direct deposits, wire transfers, online bill payments, and debit or credit card transactions. P2P payment services are a specific type of EFT that allow you to link your bank account, debit card, or credit card to an app or a platform, and then use it to send or request money from other users. Some examples of popular P2P payment services are PayPal, Venmo, Cash App, and Zelle.

2 Pros of P2P payment services

One of the main advantages of P2P payment services is convenience. You can use them anytime, anywhere, with just a few taps on your phone or clicks on your computer. You don't need to know the recipient's bank details, or carry cash or checks. You can also use them for a variety of purposes, such as splitting bills, paying rent, sending gifts, or donating to causes. Another benefit of P2P payment services is speed. Most of them process transactions instantly or within minutes, unlike bank transfers that can take days or weeks. Some P2P payment services also offer rewards, discounts, or cashback for using them.

3 Cons of P2P payment services

One of the main disadvantages of P2P payment services is security. Although they use encryption and other measures to protect your data and transactions, they are not immune to hacking, phishing, fraud, or scams. You should always verify the identity and legitimacy of the person you are sending or receiving money from, and avoid sharing your personal or financial information with anyone. You should also review the terms and conditions of the service you are using, and understand the fees, limits, and policies that apply. Another drawback of P2P payment services is regulation. Unlike banks, they are not subject to the same federal and state laws and regulations that protect your deposits, rights, and privacy. If you have a dispute or a problem with a P2P payment service, you may not have the same recourse or protection as you would with a bank.

4 How bank transfers work

Bank transfers are another type of EFT that involve moving money from one bank account to another. They can be domestic or international, and they can be initiated online, by phone, or in person. To make a bank transfer, you need to know the recipient's name, bank name, account number, and routing number. Some banks may also require a SWIFT code or an IBAN for international transfers. You can also use a third-party service, such as Western Union or MoneyGram, to transfer money from your bank account to a cash pickup location.

5 Pros of bank transfers

One of the main advantages of bank transfers is security. Banks are regulated by federal and state agencies, such as the FDIC and the NCUA, that insure your deposits up to a certain limit and enforce consumer protection laws and regulations. Banks also have sophisticated security systems and protocols to prevent and detect fraud and identity theft. If you have a problem or a dispute with a bank transfer, you can contact your bank or the regulatory agency for assistance or resolution. Another benefit of bank transfers is reliability. Bank transfers are widely accepted and recognized as a valid and official form of payment. They can also handle larger amounts and currencies than most P2P payment services.

6 Cons of bank transfers

One of the main disadvantages of bank transfers is cost. Banks usually charge fees for sending or receiving money, especially for international transfers. The fees may vary depending on the amount, the destination, the method, and the service provider. You may also incur additional fees from intermediary banks or currency conversion rates. Another drawback of bank transfers is speed. Bank transfers can take longer than P2P payment services to process and clear, depending on the bank, the service provider, and the country. They may also be subject to delays, errors, or cancellations due to human or technical factors.

7 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?