What are the most effective ways to monitor and control bioreactor temperature?

1 Why is temperature important?

Temperature influences the rate of biochemical reactions, the activity and stability of enzymes and proteins, the fluid properties and mass transfer, and the microbial physiology and morphology. Different types of bioreactors and cultures may have different optimal temperature ranges, depending on the type of organism, substrate, product, and process. For example, mesophilic bacteria typically grow best between 20°C and 45°C, while thermophilic bacteria can tolerate temperatures above 50°C. Similarly, mammalian cells require lower temperatures than bacterial cells, usually around 37°C. Temperature deviations can cause undesirable effects, such as reduced growth, altered metabolism, increased byproducts, decreased product yield and quality, and cell death.

2 How to measure temperature?

Temperature can be measured by various sensors, such as thermocouples, thermistors, resistance temperature detectors (RTDs), or infrared thermometers. The choice of sensor depends on factors such as accuracy, response time, durability, cost, and compatibility with the bioreactor system. The sensor should be calibrated and validated before and after each use, and placed in a representative location within the bioreactor. The sensor should also be sterilized and protected from contamination and corrosion. The temperature data should be recorded and displayed in real time, and integrated with the control system.

3 How to control temperature?

Temperature can be controlled by adjusting the heat transfer between the bioreactor and the surroundings, using heating or cooling devices. The most common devices are jacketed vessels, which circulate a fluid with a controlled temperature around the bioreactor; or internal coils, which are immersed in the bioreactor and carry a heating or cooling fluid. Other devices include external heat exchangers, which pump the bioreactor contents through a heat exchange unit; or electrical heaters, which generate heat by passing a current through a resistive element. The temperature control system should be designed to maintain a constant and uniform temperature throughout the bioreactor, and to respond quickly and accurately to changes in the heat generation or removal.

4 What are the challenges of temperature control?

Temperature control can present several challenges, such as heat generation, removal, and transfer. The biological reactions in the bioreactor can generate heat, which can vary depending on the growth phase, substrate concentration, oxygen uptake, and product formation. This heat must be removed by a cooling device that is able to handle peak heat load and prevent overcooling. Heat transfer between the bioreactor and the cooling device is influenced by the geometry, material, and surface area of the device, as well as the fluid properties, flow rate, and turbulence. Over time, this heat transfer coefficient can change due to fouling, scaling, or corrosion of the device. Additionally, it can differ between the bioreactor and cooling device, causing a temperature difference or lag.

5 What are the solutions for temperature control?

In order to overcome the challenges of temperature control, there are a few possible solutions that can be implemented. Optimizing the bioreactor design and operation can help minimize heat losses or gains, and maximize the heat transfer area and efficiency. Additionally, advanced control strategies such as proportional-integral-derivative (PID), fuzzy logic, neural network, or model predictive control (MPC) can be used to adjust the heating or cooling device output. Furthermore, online monitoring and diagnostics can provide real-time information and feedback to detect any deviations or faults in the temperature control system. This system can also use diagnostics and optimization techniques such as statistical process control (SPC), fault detection and isolation (FDI), or process analytical technology (PAT) to identify and eliminate sources of variability or inefficiency. By utilizing these solutions, the challenges associated with temperature control can be effectively overcome.

6 How to evaluate temperature control?

Temperature control can be evaluated by various criteria, such as setpoint accuracy, control stability, control robustness, and control efficiency. Setpoint accuracy measures how close the actual temperature is to the desired temperature, and can be expressed by the mean error, standard deviation, or root mean square error (RMSE) of the temperature deviation. Control stability measures how stable the actual temperature is around the desired temperature, and can be expressed by the oscillation frequency, amplitude, or damping ratio of the temperature deviation. Control robustness measures how well the temperature control system can cope with disturbances or uncertainties, such as changes in the heat generation or removal, and can be expressed by the sensitivity, resilience, or reliability of the system. Lastly, control efficiency measures how efficiently the temperature control system uses resources like energy and water and can be expressed by energy consumption, water consumption, or control time.

7 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?