What are the current and future market opportunities and barriers for underground caverns for CAES?

1 How does CAES work?

CAES uses electricity to compress air and store it in underground caverns, such as salt domes, depleted oil and gas reservoirs, or hard rock formations. When the electricity demand is high, the compressed air is released and heated by natural gas or other fuels to drive a turbine and generate power. CAES can have two modes: diabatic and adiabatic. Diabatic CAES releases the heat generated by compression to the environment, while adiabatic CAES stores the heat and uses it to reheat the air during expansion, improving the efficiency and reducing the emissions.

2 What are the benefits of CAES?

CAES has several advantages over other energy storage technologies, such as batteries, pumped hydro, or flywheels. CAES can store large amounts of energy for long durations, ranging from hours to days, and can respond quickly to grid fluctuations. CAES can also integrate well with variable renewable energy sources, such as wind and solar, by absorbing their excess output and smoothing their intermittency. Moreover, CAES can provide ancillary services to the grid, such as frequency regulation, voltage support, and spinning reserve, enhancing the reliability and stability of the system.

3 What are the challenges of CAES?

Despite its potential benefits, CAES also faces some significant challenges that hinder its widespread adoption and deployment. One of the main challenges is the high capital cost and long lead time of developing underground caverns for CAES. The site selection, engineering, construction, and permitting of these facilities can take several years and require large upfront investments. Another challenge is the low round-trip efficiency and high carbon footprint of diabatic CAES, which relies on natural gas combustion to heat the air. This reduces the environmental benefits and economic competitiveness of CAES compared to other low-carbon energy storage options. A third challenge is the limited availability and suitability of underground caverns for CAES. Not all regions have geologically suitable formations that can withstand high pressure and prevent air leakage. Moreover, some of these formations may be already used or reserved for other purposes, such as natural gas storage, oil and gas production, or water supply.

4 What are the opportunities for CAES?

Despite these challenges, there are also some promising opportunities for CAES to overcome its barriers and increase its market share. One of the opportunities is to improve the technology and design of CAES systems, especially adiabatic CAES, which can achieve higher efficiency and lower emissions by using thermal energy storage instead of natural gas. Another opportunity is to explore alternative sites and methods for storing compressed air, such as abandoned mines, aquifers, or artificial reservoirs, which may offer lower cost, higher availability, and greater flexibility. A third opportunity is to leverage the existing infrastructure and synergies of CAES with other energy sectors, such as natural gas pipelines, power plants, or hydrogen production, which can reduce the capital cost, increase the revenue streams, and enhance the integration of CAES with the grid.

5 What are the future trends for CAES?

The future of CAES depends on various factors, including policy and regulation, market conditions and incentives, technological innovation and development, and social and environmental impacts. Possible scenarios for CAES include becoming a niche technology only deployed in certain regions or applications, becoming a mainstream technology across different regions and applications, or becoming a transitional technology that is gradually replaced by other energy storage options. CAES could provide ancillary services or support isolated grids, complement and optimize the use of renewable energy sources, or provide bulk energy storage or peak shaving. Alternatives to CAES that may be more efficient, cost-effective, and environmentally friendly include batteries, hydrogen, or thermal storage.

6 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?