登录查看更多内容

点击“继续加入或登录”，即表示您同意遵守领英的《用户协议》、《隐私政策》及《Cookie 政策》。

What are the best practices for blinding in experimental studies?

由人工智能和领英社区提供技术支持

Blinding is a technique that reduces bias and confounding in experimental studies by concealing the identity or characteristics of the intervention, the outcome, or both, from the participants, the investigators, or the evaluators. Blinding can enhance the validity and reliability of the results, as well as the ethical and scientific standards of the research. In this article, you will learn about the best practices for blinding in experimental studies, and how to apply them in different contexts and scenarios.

此文章中的业界达人

由社区从 7 条内容中精选。了解更多

Dr. Sanaullah Sajid

Chief Executive Officer @ PRISM-CRO | Academic Editor @ PLOS | Postdoctoral Scientist @ Guangdong Medical University
Dr. Jefferson do Rosário

Head of Business Development Office @ DESY - the German Electron Synchrotron | Development of new markets | Technology…

1 Types of blinding

The selection of the type of blinding for a research project depends on the research question, feasibility, and potential sources of bias. The most common types of blinding are single-blind, double-blind, triple-blind, and quadruple-blind. In a single-blind study, the participants are unaware of the intervention or outcome, while the investigators and evaluators are not. In a double-blind study, both the participants and investigators are unaware of the intervention, but the evaluators know. For a triple-blind study, all three parties (participants, investigators, and evaluators) are unaware of the intervention. Lastly, a quadruple-blind study ensures that all four parties (participants, investigators, evaluators, and data analysts) are unaware of the intervention.

添加您的观点

Dr. Jefferson do Rosário

Head of Business Development Office @ DESY - the German Electron Synchrotron | Development of new markets | Technology roadmaps | R&D Management | IP Strategy
举报内容
A well-crafted observation, emphasizing the nuanced considerations in selecting blinding methods for research. The succinct breakdown of single-blind, double-blind, triple-blind, and quadruple-blind studies effectively captures the diverse levels of awareness among participants, investigators, evaluators, and data analysts.

已翻译

赞

2 Benefits of blinding

Blinding can provide several benefits for experimental studies, such as reducing the placebo effect, the Hawthorne effect, and the observer bias. The placebo effect is the improvement in the outcome due to the expectation or belief that the intervention is effective, rather than its actual effect. The Hawthorne effect is the change in the behavior or performance of the participants due to the awareness of being observed or measured. The observer bias is the distortion in the measurement or interpretation of the outcome due to the preference or expectation of the investigators or evaluators. Blinding can prevent participants from being influenced by their knowledge of the intervention, as well as protect investigators and evaluators from distorting their measurements or interpretations due to their expectations.

添加您的观点

Dr. Jefferson do Rosário

Head of Business Development Office @ DESY - the German Electron Synchrotron | Development of new markets | Technology roadmaps | R&D Management | IP Strategy
举报内容
This succinctly explains the crucial role of blinding in experimental studies by addressing three key biases: placebo effect, Hawthorne effect, and observer bias. The comment effectively communicates the purpose of blinding in ensuring the integrity and reliability of study outcomes.

已翻译

赞

3 Challenges of blinding

Blinding can present some challenges for experimental studies, such as increasing complexity and cost due to extra resources and procedures required. It can also reduce the applicability and generalizability of results, as some interventions or outcomes may not be suitable to blind in real-world settings. Moreover, there is a risk of unblinding, which is the accidental or intentional disclosure of the identity or characteristics of the intervention or the outcome, potentially compromising the validity and reliability of the results. Unblinding can be caused by adverse events, protocol deviations, data leaks, or participant requests.

添加您的观点

Dr. Jefferson do Rosário

Head of Business Development Office @ DESY - the German Electron Synchrotron | Development of new markets | Technology roadmaps | R&D Management | IP Strategy
举报内容
An insightful exploration of the benefits of blinding in experimental studies, highlighting its role in mitigating the placebo effect, Hawthorne effect, and observer bias. The detailed explanation of these phenomena enhances understanding, emphasizing how blinding safeguards against participant influence and shields investigators and evaluators from potential distortions arising from preconceptions.

已翻译

赞

4 Strategies for blinding

To maximize the benefits of blinding and overcome its challenges, you can utilize a variety of strategies. Choosing the appropriate type and level of blinding is essential, taking into account feasibility, cost, and ethical implications. Placebo or sham interventions can be used to blind participants and investigators, as well as control for the placebo effect. Dummy or masked outcomes can be used to blind participants, investigators, or evaluators, while controlling for the Hawthorne effect or observer bias. Independent or blinded evaluators can reduce observer bias and ensure accuracy of outcome assessment. Randomization and allocation concealment can help reduce selection bias and ensure comparability and balance of groups. Codes or labels can maintain confidentiality and security of blinding, as well as facilitate communication and documentation of research. Finally, blinding protocols and checklists can standardize and document the blinding process, as well as prevent or detect unblinding.

添加您的观点

Dr. Jefferson do Rosário

Head of Business Development Office @ DESY - the German Electron Synchrotron | Development of new markets | Technology roadmaps | R&D Management | IP Strategy
举报内容
A comprehensive overview of strategies to enhance the effectiveness of blinding in research. This comment adeptly captures the importance of selecting the right type and level of blinding while considering practical, ethical, and cost factors. The mention of placebo interventions, dummy outcomes, independent evaluators, and other strategies demonstrates a nuanced understanding of how these techniques can address specific biases and challenges in experimental studies. The emphasis on protocols and checklists adds a valuable dimension by highlighting the role of standardization and documentation in maintaining the integrity of the blinding process.

已翻译

赞
Dr. Sanaullah Sajid

Chief Executive Officer @ PRISM-CRO | Academic Editor @ PLOS | Postdoctoral Scientist @ Guangdong Medical University
举报内容
Here are some strategies: 1. Single-blind Design 2. Double-blind Design 3. Triple-blind Design 4. Use of Placebos 5. Randomization 6. Objective Measurements 7. Training Staff 8. Sealed Envelope Technique 9. Independent Monitoring 10. Automated Systems

已翻译

赞

5 Assessing the blinding

You can evaluate the effectiveness and quality of the blinding by asking participants, investigators, or evaluators to guess which intervention they received, delivered, or evaluated and report their confidence level and reasons for their guess. This can be compared to the actual assignments and the proportion of correct guesses, agreement rate, or kappa statistic can be calculated. Additionally, you can measure the outcomes or behaviors of the participants, investigators, or evaluators that may indicate or reflect their knowledge or expectation of the intervention. Any significant differences or associations between these measures can be tested across groups. Lastly, any incidents or events that may have caused or revealed unblinding should be reported with information on frequency, severity, and impact on results. Any actions or measures taken to prevent or address unblinding should also be documented.

添加您的观点

Dr. Sanaullah Sajid

Chief Executive Officer @ PRISM-CRO | Academic Editor @ PLOS | Postdoctoral Scientist @ Guangdong Medical University
举报内容
Assessing the effectiveness of blinding in experimental studies is crucial to ensure the integrity and reliability of the study's outcomes. Here are several methods to assess blinding: 1. Post-Study Interviews or Surveys 2. Guessing Patterns Analysis 3. Statistical Tests 4. Blinding Index 5. Independent Audits 6. Review of Protocol Adherence 7. Assessment of Side Effects 8. Monitoring Data Quality and Consistency 9. Investigating Breaks in Blinding 10. Ethical and Regulatory Compliance Check These methods, used individually or in combination, can help assess the effectiveness of blinding in experimental studies, thus providing insights into the reliability of the study results.

已翻译

赞
Dr. Jefferson do Rosário

Head of Business Development Office @ DESY - the German Electron Synchrotron | Development of new markets | Technology roadmaps | R&D Management | IP Strategy
举报内容
The suggestion to inquire about participants', investigators', or evaluators' guesses and confidence levels, coupled with comparing these with actual assignments, is a practical approach. The mention of statistical measures like agreement rate and kappa statistic adds a quantitative dimension to the evaluation process. Furthermore, the recommendation to examine outcomes or behaviors indicating knowledge or expectation of the intervention and testing for differences across groups contributes to a thorough evaluation.

已翻译

赞

6 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

添加您的观点

Product R&D

+ 关注

给文章评分

我们借助人工智能创建了此文章。您认为这篇文章怎么样？

很棒不太好

举报此文章

查看全部

What are the best practices for blinding in experimental studies?

1

2

3

4

5

6

1 Types of blinding

2 Benefits of blinding

3 Challenges of blinding

4 Strategies for blinding

5 Assessing the blinding

6 Here’s what else to consider

Product R&D

给文章评分

感谢您的反馈

更多Product R&D相关文章

更多相关阅读内容

What are the best practices for blinding in experimental studies?

1

2

3

4

5

6

1 Types of blinding

2 Benefits of blinding

3 Challenges of blinding

4 Strategies for blinding

5 Assessing the blinding

6 Here’s what else to consider

Product R&D

给文章评分

感谢您的反馈

查看其他技能