What are the advantages and limitations of different deformation mechanisms in materials design?

1 Elastic deformation

Elastic deformation is the reversible change in shape or size of a material under stress, without breaking or altering its atomic bonds. It is governed by Hooke's law, which states that the stress is proportional to the strain within the elastic limit. Elastic deformation is desirable for materials that need to withstand small or temporary loads without permanent damage, such as springs, rubber bands, and some biological tissues. However, elastic deformation also has limitations, such as the low amount of energy that can be stored or dissipated, the narrow range of stress that can be tolerated, and the possible anisotropy of the material's elastic response.

2 Plastic deformation

Plastic deformation is the irreversible change in shape or size of a material under stress, due to the permanent displacement or rearrangement of its atoms. It is governed by the yield strength, which is the stress level at which plastic deformation begins. Plastic deformation is desirable for materials that need to accommodate large or permanent loads without fracturing, such as metals, alloys, and polymers. However, plastic deformation also has limitations, such as the loss of dimensional stability, the reduction of ductility and toughness, and the generation of residual stresses and defects.

3 Dislocation motion

Dislocation motion is one of the most important plastic deformation mechanisms in crystalline materials, such as metals and ceramics. It involves the movement of dislocations, which are linear defects in the crystal lattice, under stress. Dislocation motion allows the material to deform plastically with less energy and stress than if the atoms had to move as a whole. It also enables the material to harden, as the dislocations interact with each other and with other obstacles, such as grain boundaries, impurities, and precipitates. However, dislocation motion also has limitations, such as the dependence on temperature, strain rate, and crystal orientation, the susceptibility to fatigue and creep, and the difficulty of controlling the dislocation density and distribution.

4 Slip and twinning

Slip and twinning are two specific modes of dislocation motion that occur in different crystal structures and stress conditions. Slip involves the shearing of one part of the crystal relative to another along a specific plane and direction, called the slip system. Twinning involves the formation of a mirror image of the crystal across a specific plane, called the twin boundary. Slip and twinning have different advantages and limitations for materials design, depending on the material's symmetry, ductility, strength, and texture. For example, slip is more common and easier in materials with high symmetry and low stacking fault energy, such as face-centered cubic metals, while twinning is more common and easier in materials with low symmetry and high stacking fault energy, such as hexagonal close-packed metals.

5 Diffusional creep

Diffusional creep is a plastic deformation mechanism that occurs in polycrystalline materials at high temperatures and low stresses. It involves the diffusion of atoms from regions of high stress to regions of low stress, either along the grain boundaries (Coble creep) or through the bulk (Nabarro-Herring creep). Diffusional creep allows the material to deform plastically without generating dislocations or other defects, which can improve its resistance to fracture and corrosion. However, diffusional creep also has limitations, such as the slow rate of deformation, the dependence on temperature and grain size, and the possible grain growth and coarsening.

6 Phase transformation

Phase transformation is a deformation mechanism that occurs in some materials when they undergo a change in their crystal structure or composition under stress. It involves the nucleation and growth of a new phase with a different lattice parameter or chemical composition, either martensitically (without diffusion) or diffusively (with diffusion). Phase transformation can enhance the mechanical properties, functionality, and adaptability of materials, as they can exhibit shape memory, superelasticity, ferroelectricity, or magnetism. However, phase transformation also has limitations, such as the hysteresis, fatigue, and degradation that can occur during repeated cycling, the sensitivity to temperature and stress, and the difficulty of achieving homogeneous and stable microstructures.

7 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?