What are the advantages and disadvantages of using hardware-based random number generators for encryption?

1 Speed and quality

One of the main advantages of hardware-based RNGs is that they can generate high-quality random numbers at a high speed. High-quality random numbers are those that are unpredictable, unbiased, and independent. These properties are crucial for ensuring the security and robustness of encryption schemes. Hardware-based RNGs can produce high-quality random numbers by exploiting the inherent randomness of physical processes, which are not affected by external factors or predictable patterns.

Hardware-based RNGs can also generate random numbers faster than software-based RNGs, which may have limited throughput or require additional processing. For example, a hardware-based RNG that uses thermal noise can generate up to 1 gigabit of random data per second, while a software-based RNG that uses a linear congruential generator can produce only about 4 megabits per second.

2 Security and trust

Another advantage of hardware-based RNGs is that they can offer higher security and trust than software-based RNGs. Software-based RNGs are vulnerable to various attacks, such as reverse engineering, tampering, or backdooring, that can compromise their randomness or leak their internal state. Software-based RNGs may also be affected by bugs, errors, or malicious code that can reduce their quality or introduce bias. Moreover, software-based RNGs depend on external sources of entropy, which may be insufficient, predictable, or manipulated.

Hardware-based RNGs, on the other hand, are more resistant to these attacks and risks, as they do not rely on software or external inputs. Hardware-based RNGs are also more transparent and verifiable, as they can be tested and certified by independent parties or standards. For example, the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) has developed a standard for testing and validating hardware-based RNGs, known as NIST SP 800-90B.

3 Cost and availability

One of the main disadvantages of hardware-based RNGs is that they can be more expensive and less available than software-based RNGs. Hardware-based RNGs require special devices or components that may not be widely accessible or affordable. For example, a hardware-based RNG that uses quantum effects may require a quantum computer or a photon detector, which are not common or cheap. Hardware-based RNGs may also incur additional costs for maintenance, calibration, or certification.

Software-based RNGs, in contrast, are more accessible and affordable, as they can be implemented on any device or platform that can run software. Software-based RNGs are also more flexible and adaptable, as they can be updated or modified according to different needs or specifications.

4 Design and testing

Another disadvantage of hardware-based RNGs is that they can be more difficult and complex to design and test than software-based RNGs. Hardware-based RNGs involve physical processes that may not be well understood or modeled, which can pose challenges for designing and optimizing them. Hardware-based RNGs may also have inherent limitations or imperfections that can affect their performance or quality. For example, a hardware-based RNG that uses radioactive decay may have a limited lifespan or a variable rate of emission.

Hardware-based RNGs also require rigorous and comprehensive testing and validation to ensure their quality and security. Hardware-based RNGs may have different sources of error or bias that can be hard to detect or correct. For example, a hardware-based RNG that uses thermal noise may be influenced by temperature, humidity, or electromagnetic interference. Hardware-based RNGs may also need to comply with various standards or regulations that can be costly or time-consuming.

5 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?