What are the advantages and disadvantages of using competitive bidding for construction procurement?

1 Advantages of competitive bidding

One of the main advantages of competitive bidding is that it can help achieve cost savings and value for money for the project owner. By inviting multiple contractors to compete for the project, the owner can compare different offers and choose the most suitable one based on the best price-quality ratio. Competitive bidding can also stimulate innovation and efficiency among contractors, as they have to find ways to differentiate themselves from their competitors and offer better solutions. Additionally, competitive bidding can enhance the credibility and accountability of the procurement process, as it follows clear and objective rules and criteria that are known to all parties.

2 Disadvantages of competitive bidding

Despite its benefits, competitive bidding also has some disadvantages that can negatively impact the project's performance and outcomes. One of the main disadvantages is that it can lead to low quality and substandard work, as some contractors may sacrifice quality and safety to lower their bids and win the project. This can result in poor workmanship, defects, delays, and rework, which can increase the project's costs and risks. Another disadvantage is that it can create adversarial and distrustful relationships between the owner and the contractor, as they may have conflicting interests and goals. Competitive bidding can also increase the likelihood of disputes and litigation, as the contractor may try to claim extra payments or compensation for unforeseen changes or problems that arise during the project.

3 How to mitigate the disadvantages of competitive bidding

To avoid or reduce some of the disadvantages of competitive bidding, there are some strategies that the owner and the contractor can adopt. One of them is to use a pre-qualification process, where the owner screens the contractors based on their experience, reputation, financial capacity, and technical skills, and only invites those who meet the minimum requirements to bid for the project. This can help ensure that the contractors are capable and reliable, and reduce the risk of low quality and non-compliance. Another strategy is to use a best value procurement approach, where the owner evaluates the bids not only based on price, but also on other factors, such as quality, innovation, sustainability, and customer satisfaction. This can help achieve a more balanced and optimal outcome for the project, and encourage the contractors to deliver high performance and value. A third strategy is to establish a collaborative and cooperative relationship between the owner and the contractor, based on trust, communication, and mutual respect. This can help prevent or resolve conflicts, and foster a positive and productive working environment.

4 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?