How do board of directors determine executive pay?

1 The role of the board of directors

The board of directors is the group of elected or appointed individuals who oversee the strategic direction and governance of a company. One of their key responsibilities is to hire, fire, and evaluate the performance of the CEO and other senior executives. They also have the authority to approve and monitor the compensation of these executives, which usually involves consulting with external experts, benchmarking against peer companies, and aligning with the company's goals and values. The board of directors typically has a compensation committee that handles the details of executive pay and makes recommendations to the full board.

2 The components of executive compensation

Executive compensation is not just a simple salary. It usually consists of several elements designed to incentivize and reward the executive for achieving short-term and long-term objectives, such as base salary, bonus, stock options, restricted stock, long-term incentive plan, and perquisites. Base salary typically reflects the market rate for similar positions, the executive's skills and experience, and the company's size and industry. Bonus is variable and paid in cash or stock based on meeting or exceeding specific targets. Stock options give the executive the opportunity to benefit from the increase in the company's value over time but also expose them to risk. Restricted stock grants shares of the company's stock with certain restrictions, such as vesting periods or performance conditions. A long-term incentive plan rewards the executive for achieving strategic goals that span multiple years. Perquisites are additional benefits or privileges that enhance the executive's quality of life or facilitate business activities.

3 The challenges and controversies of executive pay

Executive pay is often subject to scrutiny and criticism from various stakeholders, such as shareholders, employees, customers, regulators, media, and society at large. Common challenges and controversies of executive pay include pay-performance alignment, pay disparity, and pay transparency. Pay-performance alignment refers to the extent to which the executive's compensation reflects their contribution to the company's success or failure. Pay disparity is the gap between the executive's compensation and the compensation of other employees or workers in the same industry or economy. Pay transparency is the level of disclosure and communication of the executive's compensation to relevant stakeholders. Ideally, executive pay should be aligned with the company's performance and shareholder value, however there may be disconnects due to factors such as market fluctuations or external influences. Excessive or unjustified pay disparity may cause resentment among lower-paid workers or the general public. Too much or too little pay transparency may have negative consequences such as litigation or misinformation.

4 The best practices for negotiating your own salary as an executive

As an executive or aspiring leader who wants to negotiate their own salary, it is important to be prepared, confident, and strategic. Doing research on the market rate for your position, the company’s financial situation and performance, the board of directors’ expectations and preferences, and the compensation of peers and competitors is essential. It is also important to assess your own value proposition, achievements, and goals, and how they align with the company’s vision and mission. During the negotiation, be flexible and creative by considering the trade-offs and implications of each element of your compensation package and proposing solutions that benefit both you and the company. Respectfulness and professionalism should be maintained throughout the negotiation by communicating clearly, listening actively, being honest and ethical, and avoiding arrogance or making unrealistic demands. Executive pay is a complex topic that requires careful decision-making by all parties involved; understanding the role of the board of directors in setting executive pay, main components of executive compensation packages, challenges and controversies of executive pay, and best practices for negotiating your own salary can help you navigate this process more effectively.

5 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?