How can game designers balance player freedom and game mechanics?

由人工智能和领英社区提供技术支持

Player freedom and game mechanics are two essential elements of game design that can create immersive and engaging experiences for gamers. However, they can also pose challenges and trade-offs for game designers who want to balance them effectively. How can game designers balance player freedom and game mechanics without compromising the quality and coherence of their games? Here are some tips and examples to consider.

此文章中的业界达人

由社区从 7 条内容中精选。了解更多

Luiz Aguiar

Porting Engineer at Mega Cat Studios
Tommy Foo

Gaming | Project Manager | Community Builder | Social Media Manager | Data Analyst | Voice of indie games |…
Tim Ryan

1 Define your core loop

The core loop is the basic cycle of actions and rewards that players repeat throughout the game. It is the foundation of your game mechanics and the main source of player motivation and satisfaction. To balance player freedom and game mechanics, you need to define your core loop clearly and make sure it is consistent, fun, and challenging. You also need to avoid adding unnecessary or conflicting mechanics that can break or dilute your core loop.

添加您的观点

Luiz Aguiar

Porting Engineer at Mega Cat Studios
举报内容
O loop de jogo é parte muito importante para trilhar o caminho da divers?o do jogador. Um bom loop de jogo permite que jogadores consigam ter uma consistência no que fazem durante a sess?o de jogo. Além de dar mais consistência, torna ainda mais claro bons momentos de aplicar novas mecanicas e tornar seu loop de jogo ainda mais diverso porém mantendo a consistência do jogo.

已翻译

赞
Tommy Foo

Gaming | Project Manager | Community Builder | Social Media Manager | Data Analyst | Voice of indie games | #OpenToNetwork
(已编辑)
举报内容
This is a portion of the game that could either make or break your a feature or the entire game. Keep your players in mind all the time when planning for this, after all the game is made for the players. Some questions you can ask yourself and the team when setting objectives surrounding the cycle. How much agency do players have when going through the loop? Are there multiple paths to this defined success, or is it more rigidly defined using a method? By completing this, does it contribute to player progression? Does it unlock new mechanics, skills (action space), or areas? You can also think along the line of players' emotion too or beyond basic rewards. The key here is to ensure optimal player experience is achieved through definition.

已翻译

赞

2 Offer meaningful choices

Player freedom is not just about letting players do whatever they want, but about giving them meaningful choices that have consequences and impact the game world and the story. To balance player freedom and game mechanics, you need to design choices that are relevant to your core loop, your game genre, and your narrative. You also need to provide feedback and rewards that reflect the outcomes of the choices and make them feel significant and satisfying.

添加您的观点

Luiz Aguiar

Porting Engineer at Mega Cat Studios
举报内容
Um jogador com escolhas, é um jogador propenso a ficar mais interessado no jogo. Este é um dos aspectos mais poderosos e um grande aliado para alcan?ar a divers?o. Precisamos avaliar que tipo de escolhas podem deixar o jogo ainda mais interessante ou desinteressante. Uma medida de peso a ser considerada é a consequência. As op??es devem n?o seguir um único caminho, mas ter suas vantagens e desvantagens de maneira única. é um conceito simples mas que tem um impacto grande na experiência de jogo como um todo.

已翻译

赞
Tommy Foo

Gaming | Project Manager | Community Builder | Social Media Manager | Data Analyst | Voice of indie games | #OpenToNetwork
举报内容
Going through this is part of mechanics design and vital for improving any existing mechanics. Players should be able to perceive a range of possible actions but not too few as it can cause boredom, neither can it be too many to the point of confusion and frustration. Ensure choices exist in variations, numerous but feel interesting to have available actions that change over time compared to choosing from same actions repeatedly. Predictability and uncertainty for the them to guesstimate outcomes to a certain degrees and for them to master this form of gameplay. There are more principles to these design pointers, it depends on the game genre, narratives and agencies you intend to give, yet this has a major factor to designing mechanics.

已翻译

赞

3 Integrate your narrative

Narrative is the way you tell your game story and communicate your game theme and message. It can be a powerful tool to enhance player freedom and game mechanics by creating immersion, emotion, and connection. To balance player freedom and game mechanics, you need to integrate your narrative into your core loop, your choices, and your feedback. You also need to adapt your narrative to different player styles, preferences, and actions.

添加您的观点

Tommy Foo

Gaming | Project Manager | Community Builder | Social Media Manager | Data Analyst | Voice of indie games | #OpenToNetwork
举报内容
Having a narrative in this can strengthen the game state by having player feel they are part of the world. There are few types of narration you can consider, through environment where the lore of the world tells the story where player can explore them to learn more and feeling a relationship to it. Character development with questions on reasons a character embark on an adventure, and the choices they consider when faced with a situation. Players should feel some agency to their own actions and when a choice is made they should feel they are part of it, with the immersive experience. Through this, player would be keen of wanting to know more and even start a discussion of players talking about it, resulting in a community growth.

已翻译

赞
Luiz Aguiar

Porting Engineer at Mega Cat Studios
举报内容
A integra??o da narrativa é uma ferramenta de alto valor na cria??o da experiência de jogo. A utiliza??o de todo o potencial dos personagens presentes s?o um verdadeiro potencializador de outras estruturas que comp?em o jogo. Desenvolvimento de personagens, estrutura de mundo e seus significados as vezes até filosóficos, tornam o jogo ainda mais interessante. é possível perceber a evolu??o narrativa ao pensar em jogos muito antigos, onde n?o controlávamos um herói ou havia uma princesa a ser salva em jogos como "Pong". A importancia do uso desses conceitos em jogos de RPG, percebemos ainda mais a busca por sensa??es diversas vinculadas a narrativa e é ainda mais presente do que em outros gêneros.

已翻译

赞

4 Use modularity and flexibility

Modularity and flexibility are the principles of designing your game in a way that allows for easy modification, expansion, and adaptation. They can help you balance player freedom and game mechanics by enabling you to create more variety, diversity, and replayability in your game. To use modularity and flexibility, you need to design your game in smaller and interchangeable components that can be combined, customized, and changed according to different scenarios, contexts, and player inputs.

添加您的观点

5 Test and iterate

Testing and iterating are the processes of evaluating and improving your game based on feedback and data. They can help you balance player freedom and game mechanics by identifying and solving any issues, gaps, or inconsistencies in your game design. To test and iterate, you need to collect and analyze feedback and data from different sources, such as playtesting, surveys, reviews, and analytics. You also need to apply the feedback and data to your game design in a way that enhances your core loop, your choices, your narrative, and your modularity and flexibility.

添加您的观点

6 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

添加您的观点

Tim Ryan
举报内容
This is really a stupid question, as player freedom is gameplay, but taking the obtuse interpretation of the balance question, it really comes down to meeting player expectations in terms of both content and player capability, which is a scope challenge for designers, but also the difficulty curve as the game tries to balance players expectations of their own ability and difficulty of the mechanics.

已翻译

赞

Gaming Industry

+ 关注

给文章评分

我们借助人工智能创建了此文章。您认为这篇文章怎么样？

很棒不太好

举报此文章

查看全部

How can game designers balance player freedom and game mechanics?

1

2

3

4

5

6

1 Define your core loop

2 Offer meaningful choices

3 Integrate your narrative

4 Use modularity and flexibility

5 Test and iterate

6 Here’s what else to consider

Gaming Industry

给文章评分

感谢您的反馈

更多Gaming Industry相关文章

更多相关阅读内容

How can game designers balance player freedom and game mechanics?

1

2

3

4

5

6

1 Define your core loop

2 Offer meaningful choices

3 Integrate your narrative

4 Use modularity and flexibility

5 Test and iterate

6 Here’s what else to consider

Gaming Industry

给文章评分

感谢您的反馈

查看其他技能